📖 Overview
So Vile a Sin is a Doctor Who novel set in the dying Earth Empire of the thirtieth century. The story centers on the Seventh Doctor and his companion Roz Forrester as they become entangled in the political machinations of the Empire's Great Houses.
The Doctor must track down a dangerous weapon while navigating complex alliances and hidden threats among Jupiter's moons. An ancient brotherhood emerges as a key player in the conflict, pursuing both power and vengeance against the crumbling Imperium Humanum.
The novel connects personal and political storylines through Roz Forrester's relationship with her prominent family house. It serves as a pivotal entry in the New Adventures series, bringing several major character arcs and storylines to their conclusion.
The narrative explores themes of loyalty, family obligation, and the tension between personal choice and historical inevitability in a vast interstellar empire. These elements combine to create a meditation on power, duty, and the price of preserving civilization.
👀 Reviews
This book received limited reader reviews, with most noting it was co-written by Kate Orman after Aaronovitch was unable to complete it due to illness. Many reviewers discussed how this impacted the final product.
Readers appreciated:
- Complex plotting involving multiple timelines
- Strong character development for companion Chris
- References to earlier Doctor Who stories
- The emotional weight of certain character deaths
Common criticisms:
- Disjointed narrative style from the two authors
- Plot threads that feel unresolved
- Too many characters to keep track of
- Pacing issues in middle sections
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.6/5 (47 ratings)
Amazon: No reviews available
"You can tell where one author stops and another begins," noted one Goodreads reviewer. Another mentioned "the story loses its way in parts but recovers for a powerful ending." Some readers found the narrative confusing, with one stating "I had to re-read sections to understand what was happening."
📚 Similar books
The Gallifrey Chronicles by Lance Parkin
This Doctor Who novel explores complex political intrigue on the Time Lords' home planet with connections to Earth's future.
The Ancestor Cell by Stephen Cole Time Lords face destruction of their civilization while confronting questions of destiny and temporal manipulation.
Dead Romance by Lawrence Miles A human woman becomes entangled in a war between cosmic powers that threatens the fabric of reality across multiple timelines.
The Book of the War by Lawrence Miles This mosaic novel documents an epic conflict between the Great Houses of the Time Lords and their enemies through interconnected entries and historical accounts.
The Taking of Planet 5 by Simon Bucher-Jones Time travelers confront ancient cosmic entities while exploring the consequences of temporal warfare on the universe.
The Ancestor Cell by Stephen Cole Time Lords face destruction of their civilization while confronting questions of destiny and temporal manipulation.
Dead Romance by Lawrence Miles A human woman becomes entangled in a war between cosmic powers that threatens the fabric of reality across multiple timelines.
The Book of the War by Lawrence Miles This mosaic novel documents an epic conflict between the Great Houses of the Time Lords and their enemies through interconnected entries and historical accounts.
The Taking of Planet 5 by Simon Bucher-Jones Time travelers confront ancient cosmic entities while exploring the consequences of temporal warfare on the universe.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔮 The book was partially completed by Kate Orman after Ben Aaronovitch fell ill, making it a unique collaborative effort in the Doctor Who novel series.
📚 Ben Aaronovitch began his career writing for Doctor Who in 1988 with the television episode "Remembrance of the Daleks," which became one of the most acclaimed stories of the classic series.
🌍 The thirtieth century setting of the novel draws inspiration from the fall of historical empires, particularly the decline of the Roman and British Empires.
🪐 The Jupiter moon setting reflects NASA's increased interest in Europa and other Jovian satellites during the 1990s, when scientists began seriously considering the possibility of life in their subsurface oceans.
⚔️ The book's exploration of powerful Houses competing for influence was written years before similar themes became popular in mainstream science fiction through works like "Dune" adaptations and "House of the Dragon."