When I Was the Greatest

Allen lives in Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn with his mom and sister, where he splits his time between boxing training and looking out for his best friend Nate and Nate's brother Prodigy (nicknamed "Pro"). The three teens become inseparable, with Allen acting as a stabilizing force for the brothers, who face their own family struggles. When the boys get invited to an exclusive party in their neighborhood, it becomes a pivotal moment that will test their friendship and force them to confront serious consequences. Their choice to attend this party sets in motion events that challenge everything they thought they knew about loyalty, family, and their place in the community. Through Allen's authentic narrative voice, his perspective illuminates the complexities of growing up in an urban environment where decisions carry real weight and reputation matters. The story examines the bonds of brotherhood - both blood and chosen - against the backdrop of a neighborhood where daily life requires careful navigation of both danger and opportunity.

Readers connect with the authentic portrayal of Brooklyn neighborhood life and strong family relationships. Many note how the book handles serious themes while maintaining an age-appropriate tone for young readers. Likes: - Natural, conversational writing style - Complex friendship dynamics - Positive male role models - Representation of characters with disabilities - Focus on consequences and responsibility Dislikes: - Slow pacing in first third of book - Some readers found the boxing storyline underdeveloped - Use of slang felt forced to some readers Ratings: Goodreads: 4.1/5 (14,000+ ratings) Amazon: 4.7/5 (1,100+ ratings) Common reader comments mention the book's emphasis on loyalty, family bonds, and making hard choices. Several reviewers highlighted how the story avoids typical inner-city stereotypes while remaining grounded in reality. Teachers frequently recommend it for reluctant teen readers, citing its engaging first-person narrative and relatable characters.

Monster by Walter Dean Myers A 16-year-old boy in juvenile detention tells his story through a screenplay format while grappling with choices, identity, and justice in Harlem.

Long Way Down by Jason Reynolds A teen contemplates avenging his brother's death during a 60-second elevator ride, where he encounters ghosts of victims of gun violence.

The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas A girl navigates two worlds between her poor neighborhood and private school while fighting for justice after witnessing her childhood friend's death by police.

All American Boys by Jason Reynolds, Brendan Kiely Two teens - one Black, one White - process the aftermath of a violent police incident that rocks their community.

Dear Martin by Nic Stone A Black teen writes letters to Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. while processing his experiences with racism, police brutality, and identity at his predominantly white prep school.

🎯 Author Jason Reynolds wrote this debut novel at age 29, while working at a retail store in Washington, DC 🎭 The novel's authentic portrayal of Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn draws from Reynolds' own experiences growing up in a similar urban neighborhood 🧶 The knitting hobby of one character (Needles) was inspired by Reynolds learning that some people with Tourette's syndrome find knitting therapeutic 🏆 The book won the American Library Association's Coretta Scott King/John Steptoe Award for New Talent in 2015 📚 Reynolds intentionally wrote the story without explicit violence or drugs, despite its urban setting, to challenge stereotypes about inner-city narratives