Push Back: Guilt in the Age of Natural Parenting

Push Back confronts popular beliefs about "natural" parenting approaches and examines the scientific evidence behind common parenting philosophies. Dr. Amy Tuteur, an obstetrician and writer, challenges the prevailing narratives around natural childbirth, breastfeeding, and attachment parenting. The book analyzes the historical context of the natural parenting movement and its connection to broader cultural trends. Tuteur presents research data and medical studies to evaluate claims made by natural parenting advocates, while sharing observations from her medical practice and interactions with parents. Dr. Tuteur argues against what she identifies as unnecessary pressure and guilt placed on modern mothers. She examines specific cases and trends to demonstrate how certain parenting philosophies may impact maternal mental health and family dynamics. The work raises questions about the intersection of science, culture, and maternal identity in contemporary society. Through its critical analysis, the book explores how idealized parenting standards affect women's choices and well-being.

Readers describe this as a data-driven critique of natural parenting movements, with many appreciating Tuteur's direct challenges to claims about home birth, attachment parenting, and breastfeeding advocacy. Positive reviews highlight: - Clear presentation of medical research and statistics - Debunking of common natural parenting myths - Support for mothers facing pressure about birth and feeding choices Common criticisms: - Combative, aggressive tone - Lacks nuance in addressing complex topics - Some readers felt it went too far in dismissing all natural approaches Ratings across platforms: Goodreads: 3.8/5 (300+ ratings) Amazon: 4.3/5 (150+ ratings) Notable reader comments: "Finally, someone speaking up against the guilt-inducing natural parenting industry" - Amazon reviewer "Important message but too antagonistic in delivery" - Goodreads reviewer "Well-researched but could have been more balanced" - Barnes & Noble reviewer

Expecting Better by Emily Oster An economist examines pregnancy and childbirth research data to challenge standard medical recommendations and cultural beliefs about pregnancy.

Cribsheet by Emily Oster A data-driven analysis of parenting choices from birth through preschool that questions conventional wisdom about child-rearing practices.

The Science of Mom by Alice Callahan A scientist and mother evaluates research behind common parenting questions to separate fact from misconception in infant care practices.

Like a Mother by Angela Garbes A journalist investigates the science, history, and cultural practices surrounding pregnancy and motherhood while questioning established maternal health narratives.

The Informed Parent by Tara Haelle, Emily Willingham Two science journalists examine research evidence behind common parenting decisions from pregnancy through early childhood.

📚 Author Amy Tuteur, MD, is a former clinical instructor at Harvard Medical School and practiced as an obstetrician-gynecologist at Beth Israel Hospital. 🤱 The book challenges the idealization of "natural" childbirth and parenting, examining how these movements can sometimes harm rather than help mothers and babies. 💭 "Push Back" directly addresses the "natural parenting" movement's historical connections to eugenics and class prejudice in the early 20th century. 📊 The book includes data showing that contemporary hospital births are dramatically safer than home births, with maternal mortality rates having decreased by 99% since the advent of modern obstetrics. 🔍 While writing this book, Tuteur drew from her experience running the blog "The Skeptical OB," where she critically examines claims made by natural childbirth advocates and alternative medicine proponents.