📖 Overview
Nashville Titans second baseman Gavin Scott's marriage is in trouble after discovering his wife Thea has been faking satisfaction in their relationship for years. In desperation, he joins a secret book club composed of Nashville's top businessmen and athletes who read romance novels to better understand women and relationships.
The men's book club guides Gavin through his marital crisis using lessons from a Regency romance novel they're reading together. Gavin works to win back Thea's trust while juggling his professional baseball career and the judgment of his teammates who discover his participation in the romance book club.
Thea faces her own journey of self-discovery as she evaluates her marriage, her identity beyond being a baseball player's wife, and her relationship with her twin sister. The story alternates between Gavin and Thea's perspectives as they navigate their marital problems.
The novel explores themes of masculinity, vulnerability, and the power of communication in relationships. Through its parallel storylines of contemporary marriage and historical romance, it examines how genre fiction can provide insights into real-world relationships.
👀 Reviews
Most readers find the premise original and humorous - professional baseball players secretly reading romance novels to improve their relationships. Many appreciate the role reversal of men learning emotional intelligence from romance books.
Readers praise:
- Realistic portrayal of marriage struggles
- Balance of humor and emotional depth
- Male perspective on romance
- Discussion of gender roles and masculinity
Common criticisms:
- Repetitive internal monologues
- Frustration with main characters' communication issues
- Some find the premise unrealistic
- Romance scenes feel formulaic to some readers
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.9/5 (86,000+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.4/5 (2,800+ ratings)
BookPage: 4/5
Reader quote: "Finally a romance novel that shows men can be vulnerable and emotional while still being masculine." - Goodreads reviewer
Critical quote: "Too much time spent in the characters' heads rehashing the same insecurities over and over." - Amazon reviewer
📚 Similar books
Fix Her Up by Tessa Bailey
A baseball player and his sister's best friend fake a relationship while he rebuilds his image and she tries to shed her reputation as the town's perpetual little sister.
The Flatshare by Beth O'Leary Two strangers share a London flat and communicate through Post-it notes while navigating their complicated lives and growing feelings for each other.
Not That Kind of Guy by Andie J. Christopher A law student and her former teaching assistant pretend to date during a work conference, leading to real feelings and personal growth.
The Friend Zone by Abby Jimenez A woman with fertility issues pushes away the perfect man who wants a big family while planning her best friend's wedding with him.
Beach Read by Emily Henry Two writers with opposite approaches to their craft swap genres for a summer to overcome writer's block and discover new perspectives on love.
The Flatshare by Beth O'Leary Two strangers share a London flat and communicate through Post-it notes while navigating their complicated lives and growing feelings for each other.
Not That Kind of Guy by Andie J. Christopher A law student and her former teaching assistant pretend to date during a work conference, leading to real feelings and personal growth.
The Friend Zone by Abby Jimenez A woman with fertility issues pushes away the perfect man who wants a big family while planning her best friend's wedding with him.
Beach Read by Emily Henry Two writers with opposite approaches to their craft swap genres for a summer to overcome writer's block and discover new perspectives on love.
🤔 Interesting facts
📚 Author Lyssa Kay Adams worked as a journalist for over a decade before becoming a romance novelist, covering everything from murder trials to high school football.
💕 The book sparked a successful series, with five additional titles following different couples in the same universe of romance-reading male athletes.
⚾ The story was partially inspired by real-life professional athletes who have admitted to being fans of romance novels.
📖 The unique premise—men reading romance novels to save their relationships—generated significant buzz in the romance community and earned the book features in Entertainment Weekly and USA Today.
🏆 The novel was named one of Amazon's Best Romances of 2019 and received a starred review from Publishers Weekly.