Holy Envy

Barbara Brown Taylor, an Episcopal priest and professor of world religions, recounts her experiences teaching undergraduate students about faiths different from their own. Through classroom visits to mosques, temples, and other houses of worship, she guides her students in exploring unfamiliar spiritual territory. The narrative follows Taylor's journey over multiple semesters as she encounters resistance, curiosity, and transformation among her students at a small Georgia college. She chronicles their fieldwork observations of religious practices and their struggles to understand beliefs that challenge their existing worldviews. This memoir combines personal reflection with academic insights about world religions, focusing on Buddhism, Islam, Hinduism, and Judaism. Taylor examines her own Christian faith through the lens of teaching other traditions, documenting both her students' learning process and her own parallel discoveries. The book raises questions about religious pluralism and the value of finding beauty in faiths beyond one's own tradition. Through Taylor's experiences, it explores the tensions between maintaining religious conviction while remaining open to truth and wisdom from other paths.

Readers appreciate Taylor's openness to learning from other faiths while maintaining her Christian identity. Many note her humility and willingness to acknowledge beauty in other traditions without attempting to convert or appropriate them. Common praise: - Thoughtful exploration of interfaith dialogue - Personal anecdotes from teaching world religions - Balance between respecting differences and finding common ground Common criticisms: - Too focused on Taylor's personal journey rather than other religions - Some found it overly careful and politically correct - Christian readers noted concerns about theological relativism Several reviewers mentioned the book helped them examine their own religious assumptions and biases. Others felt it didn't go deep enough into the religions discussed. Ratings: Goodreads: 4.2/5 (3,800+ ratings) Amazon: 4.6/5 (530+ ratings) BookBrowse: 4.5/5 Representative review: "Taylor shows how to appreciate other faiths without compromising your own beliefs" - Amazon reviewer

The Heart of Christianity by Marcus Borg A Christian theologian explores other faiths to illuminate fresh perspectives on his own tradition while advocating for religious pluralism.

The Faith Club by Ranya Idliby, Suzanne Oliver, and Priscilla Warner Three women from Muslim, Christian, and Jewish backgrounds share their interfaith dialogue journey and spiritual transformations.

Without Buddha I Could Not Be a Christian by Paul F. Knitter A Catholic theologian examines how Buddhist teachings enhanced his understanding of Christianity and fostered deeper interfaith connections.

My Jesus Year by Benyamin Cohen An Orthodox Jewish rabbi's son spends a year exploring Christian churches and communities to understand his neighbors' faith.

The Meaning of Mary Magdalene by Cynthia Bourgeault An Episcopal priest combines Christian, Buddhist, and Islamic perspectives to uncover new interpretations of biblical figures and teachings.

🌟 Barbara Brown Taylor was named one of TIME magazine's most influential people in 2014 and has been called "one of the twelve most effective preachers in the English language." 🌟 The book's title "Holy Envy" comes from Christian theologian Krister Stendahl's three rules of religious understanding, which include having respect for other faiths and leaving room for "holy envy" of certain elements in other traditions. 🌟 The author spent over 20 years teaching World Religions at Piedmont College, and this book emerged from her experiences introducing students to faiths different from their own. 🌟 While teaching about other religions, Taylor discovered that learning about different faiths deepened her understanding of her own Christian faith rather than diminishing it. 🌟 The book explores visits to temples, mosques, and other sacred spaces across multiple faiths, including Buddhism, Hinduism, Islam, and Judaism, providing firsthand accounts of various religious practices and ceremonies.