📖 Overview
Kyle Donohue is running home from school on September 11, 2001, when he discovers a girl covered in ash on the Brooklyn Bridge. The girl seems to have amnesia and can't remember who she is, leading Kyle to bring her to his apartment to keep her safe during the chaos.
While caring for the mysterious girl, Kyle must also help his family cope with the unfolding tragedy. His father works with the NYPD rescue crews at Ground Zero, his uncle is paralyzed and requires constant care, and his mother and sister are stranded out of state.
Set over the course of three days following 9/11, the story follows Kyle and the nameless girl as they navigate their growing connection amid the uncertainty and grief that permeates New York City. The parallel narratives shift between Kyle's straightforward prose and the girl's more abstract poetry-like passages.
The novel explores themes of memory, identity, and human connection during times of crisis. Through its teenage protagonists, it offers perspective on how young people process and find hope during historical moments of collective trauma.
👀 Reviews
Readers commend the book's portrayal of post-9/11 New York City through teenage perspectives, with many noting its success at capturing both the confusion and human connection during a crisis. Multiple reviews mention the authentic depiction of trauma and healing.
Readers appreciated:
- The tender relationship development between main characters
- Integration of poetry throughout the narrative
- Historical accuracy and attention to detail
- Age-appropriate handling of difficult subject matter
Common criticisms:
- Pacing issues in the middle section
- Some found the prose style overly simple
- A few felt the ending wrapped up too quickly
Ratings across platforms:
Goodreads: 4.0/5 (2,800+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.4/5 (130+ ratings)
Barnes & Noble: 4.3/5 (40+ ratings)
One frequent reader comment notes: "The book manages to be both heartbreaking and hopeful without becoming melodramatic." Several teachers report successfully using it in middle school classrooms to discuss historical events.
📚 Similar books
Looking for Alaska by John Green
A story of grief and healing follows a teenage boy who forms a profound connection with a mysterious girl at boarding school during a time of personal crisis.
The Things They Carried by Tim O'Brien The interconnected stories chronicle soldiers' experiences during and after the Vietnam War through objects that hold deep personal meaning.
Between Shades of Gray by Ruta Sepetys A teenage girl documents her family's deportation to Siberia through art while navigating survival and first love during World War II.
All We Have Left by Wendy Mills Two narratives interweave between a Muslim teen experiencing 9/11 firsthand and a present-day girl uncovering truths about her brother who died in the towers.
The Sky Is Everywhere by Jandy Nelson A young musician processes the death of her sister through poetry and an unexpected romance while piecing together fragments of their shared past.
The Things They Carried by Tim O'Brien The interconnected stories chronicle soldiers' experiences during and after the Vietnam War through objects that hold deep personal meaning.
Between Shades of Gray by Ruta Sepetys A teenage girl documents her family's deportation to Siberia through art while navigating survival and first love during World War II.
All We Have Left by Wendy Mills Two narratives interweave between a Muslim teen experiencing 9/11 firsthand and a present-day girl uncovering truths about her brother who died in the towers.
The Sky Is Everywhere by Jandy Nelson A young musician processes the death of her sister through poetry and an unexpected romance while piecing together fragments of their shared past.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔹 The book takes place on September 11, 2001, and follows two teenagers in the immediate aftermath of the attacks, capturing a pivotal moment in American history through young eyes.
🔹 Author Gae Polisner was inspired to write the story after her own experience as a Long Island resident on 9/11, watching the second plane hit the World Trade Center from her local beach.
🔹 The mysterious girl in the story wears wings made from burned papers that actually fell from the Twin Towers - a detail based on real accounts of papers floating across the East River to Brooklyn.
🔹 The main character Kyle's father is a NYPD officer, reflecting the experiences of many first responder families who were separated during the chaos of 9/11.
🔹 Throughout the novel, Polisner weaves in references to the ancient Japanese art of kintsugi - the practice of repairing broken pottery with gold, making it more beautiful for having been broken.