📖 Overview
Adrian Simcox tells his classmates he owns a horse, but Chloe knows this cannot be true. She sees Adrian's worn clothes and free lunch tickets, and becomes frustrated when others believe his stories about his beautiful horse.
Chloe's mother helps her view Adrian's claims from a different perspective. Through their interactions, Chloe begins to understand more about Adrian's life circumstances and his reasons for talking about his horse.
The story explores empathy, imagination, and understanding across social barriers. It presents themes of kindness and the power of dreams, while tackling concepts of economic differences among children in an accessible way.
👀 Reviews
Readers appreciate the book's message about empathy, judgment, and socioeconomic differences. Many parents note it provides a natural way to discuss poverty and privilege with children. The illustrations by Corinna Luyken receive consistent praise for their use of color and emotion.
From reviews: "Perfect for teaching kids about perspective and not judging others by appearances" (Goodreads). Multiple teachers mention using it successfully in classroom discussions about bullying and assumptions.
Some readers find the ending too ambiguous for young children. A few note that the protagonist's initial unkindness might need additional context for the youngest readers.
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.4/5 (2,100+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.8/5 (300+ ratings)
School Library Journal: Starred Review
The book appears on multiple school reading lists and won the 2019 Comstock Read Aloud Book Award. Teachers frequently mention using it during the first week of school to build classroom community.
📚 Similar books
Those Shoes by Maribeth Boelts
A boy who cannot afford the trendy shoes he wants learns about the difference between needs and wants, and discovers the power of generosity.
Each Kindness by Jacqueline Woodson A girl reflects on her missed opportunities to show kindness to a new classmate who couldn't afford nice things.
A Bike Like Sergio's by Maribeth Boelts A child faces a moral decision when he finds money that would allow him to buy the bicycle he desires but cannot afford.
The Last Stop on Market Street by Matt de la Peña A boy and his grandmother take a bus ride through the city, revealing the beauty in their everyday life despite not having material luxuries.
Yard Sale by Eve Bunting A child processes complex emotions when her family must sell their belongings and move to a smaller home due to financial circumstances.
Each Kindness by Jacqueline Woodson A girl reflects on her missed opportunities to show kindness to a new classmate who couldn't afford nice things.
A Bike Like Sergio's by Maribeth Boelts A child faces a moral decision when he finds money that would allow him to buy the bicycle he desires but cannot afford.
The Last Stop on Market Street by Matt de la Peña A boy and his grandmother take a bus ride through the city, revealing the beauty in their everyday life despite not having material luxuries.
Yard Sale by Eve Bunting A child processes complex emotions when her family must sell their belongings and move to a smaller home due to financial circumstances.
🤔 Interesting facts
🐎 Author Marcy Campbell wrote this debut picture book after observing how her own children interacted with classmates from different economic backgrounds
📚 The book addresses complex themes of empathy, socioeconomic differences, and imagination in a way that's accessible to young readers ages 4-8
🎨 Illustrator Corinna Luyken used a limited color palette dominated by orange and blue tones to create the book's distinctive artwork
🌟 The story was inspired by Campbell's childhood memories of a boy who claimed to have a horse, which no one believed because his family was poor
🏆 The book received multiple honors, including being named a Junior Library Guild Selection and appearing on the 2019 Notable Social Studies Trade Books for Young People list