The First Paul

The First Paul examines the historical figure of Paul the Apostle through critical biblical scholarship. Authors Marcus Borg and John Dominic Crossan analyze the authenticity of Paul's letters and present evidence for which epistles Paul likely wrote himself versus those written by later authors in his name. The book contrasts three different versions of Paul that emerge from the texts: the radical Paul of the authentic letters, the conservative Paul of disputed authorship, and the reactionary Paul of later interpretations. This analysis focuses on Paul's teachings about equality, justice, and freedom within the context of the Roman Empire. The authors investigate how Paul's message transformed from its radical origins to become a tool supporting hierarchical power structures in both church and society. Their research draws connections between Paul's original vision and modern liberation movements. Through their reconstruction of the historical Paul, Borg and Crossan present core questions about the relationship between faith and empire, individual freedom versus institutional authority, and the evolution of religious movements over time. The work challenges readers to reconsider conventional interpretations of Pauline theology.

Readers describe this as an accessible examination of Paul's letters that distinguishes between the authentic Paul and later attributions. Many appreciate how it contextualizes Paul's writings within Roman imperial culture and explains contradictions between different biblical texts. Readers liked: - Clear explanations of historical context - Discussion of translation issues from Greek - Analysis of which letters Paul actually wrote - Focus on Paul's radical social message Readers disliked: - Liberal theological perspective that some found too revisionist - Repetitive content from authors' previous works - Dismissal of traditional interpretations - Academic tone in some sections From a religious scholar on Amazon: "The authors make a compelling case for Paul as a radical voice for equality, though some may struggle with their deconstruction of traditional views." Ratings: Goodreads: 4.0/5 (1,129 ratings) Amazon: 4.3/5 (164 ratings)

Jesus: A New Vision by Marcus Borg This book examines historical Jesus research through modern scholarship and focuses on Jesus as a Jewish mystic and social prophet.

The Historical Jesus by John Dominic Crossan The book reconstructs the life of Jesus through archaeological evidence and cross-cultural anthropology.

Paul: A Biography by N.T. Wright The book traces Paul's journey from zealous persecutor to Christian apostle through historical and cultural contexts.

Paul and Jesus by James D. Tabor This work explores the differences between Paul's interpretation of Christianity and Jesus's original Jewish teachings.

From Jesus to Christianity by L. Michael White The book chronicles the transformation of the Jesus movement into early Christianity through social and historical perspectives.

🔸 Marcus Borg and John Dominic Crossan argue that only 7 of the 13 letters traditionally attributed to Paul were actually written by him, with the others being written by later authors in Paul's name—a common practice in the ancient world. 📜 The book presents three different versions of Paul that have emerged through history: the radical Paul (authentic letters), the conservative Paul (disputed letters), and the reactionary Paul (pastoral letters). ⚔️ The authors challenge the common view that Paul supported slavery and subjugation of women, arguing instead that the authentic Paul was a radical social reformer who advocated for equality. 🏛️ Paul's message of equality and resistance to Roman imperial theology made him so dangerous that he was ultimately executed by Rome—the only apostle known to have been killed by the empire. 🤝 The book reveals how Paul's original message of radical equality was gradually transformed and domesticated by later writers to make it more acceptable to Roman society and authority.