The Girls Who Went Away: The Hidden History of Women Who Surrendered Children for Adoption in the Decades Before Roe v. Wade

The Girls Who Went Away examines the experiences of women who surrendered their babies for adoption between 1945 and 1973. Through interviews with over 100 women, author Ann Fessler documents the social pressures, family dynamics, and institutional systems that led unmarried pregnant women to give up their children during this era. The book presents first-person accounts from women who were sent to maternity homes and forced to navigate a complex web of shame, secrecy, and limited choices. Fessler contextualizes these personal narratives within the broader social landscape of post-war America, examining how gender roles, sexuality, and family expectations shaped these women's outcomes. The narratives trace each woman's journey from pregnancy discovery through their time in maternity homes and the aftermath of adoption. The accounts reveal the long-term psychological impact on birth mothers who were often told to forget their experiences and move forward with their lives. This work stands as both historical documentation and social commentary on reproductive rights, women's autonomy, and the lasting effects of cultural shame and stigma. The collected stories illuminate patterns of institutional power and gender-based constraints that continue to resonate in contemporary discussions of reproductive justice.

Readers describe this book as emotionally intense and eye-opening, with many noting they couldn't put it down. The oral histories hit home for both birth mothers who lived through the era and younger readers learning about these experiences for the first time. Readers appreciate: - First-hand accounts that capture the social pressures and shame - Clear explanation of historical context - Documentation of how families and institutions treated unwed mothers - Balanced tone that lets the women's stories speak for themselves Common criticisms: - Repetitive stories with similar patterns - Limited focus on middle-class white women's experiences - Some readers wanted more analysis of adoption industry practices Ratings: Goodreads: 4.3/5 (14,000+ ratings) Amazon: 4.7/5 (1,000+ ratings) Notable reader comment: "Should be required reading for anyone involved in adoption or reproductive rights discussions. These women's voices needed to be heard." - Goodreads reviewer

Wake Up Little Susie by Rickie Solinger This history documents how race and class shaped the treatment of unwed mothers in postwar America through archival research and first-hand accounts.

The House of Seven Gables by Ellen Herman A comprehensive examination of adoption practices in twentieth-century America reveals connections between social welfare policies, family formation, and cultural beliefs.

Hidden in Plain Sight: The Tragedy of Children's Rights from Ben Franklin to Lionel Tate by Barbara Bennett Woodhouse Through case studies and legal analysis, this work traces the evolution of children's rights in America, including practices of family separation and adoption.

Beggars and Choosers: How the Politics of Choice Shapes Adoption, Abortion, and Welfare in the United States by Rickie Solinger This analysis explores how concepts of choice and rights have influenced reproductive politics and adoption practices in the United States.

American Baby: A Mother, a Child, and the Shadow History of Adoption by Gabrielle Glaser Through one mother's story, this work exposes the adoption industry's impact on unmarried mothers and their children in post-World War II America.

📚 Author Ann Fessler was herself adopted and discovered her birth mother in 1989, which inspired her to document these women's stories through oral histories. 🎬 The book began as an art installation featuring video interviews, which Fessler created after receiving a Radcliffe Fellowship at Harvard University. 💔 Between 1945 and 1973, an estimated 1.5 million unwed American mothers were pressured into surrendering their babies for adoption, often at maternity homes run by religious organizations. 🤫 Many of the women interviewed had kept their pregnancies and subsequent adoptions secret for decades, even from their current families and other children. 📋 The book is based on more than 100 personal interviews with women who surrendered children during this period, though Fessler interviewed over 200 women in total during her research.