The Killing of History

The Killing of History examines how postmodern theories and cultural relativism have influenced historical scholarship. Windschuttle argues that these approaches threaten traditional historical methods focused on evidence and truth. The book analyzes specific cases where postmodern interpretations have been applied to historical events and academic disciplines. Through detailed critiques, Windschuttle challenges prominent theorists and academics who reject objective approaches to historical research. He presents arguments for maintaining empirical and rational methods in historical study, while documenting the spread of relativist thinking across universities. The text includes examinations of anthropology, archaeology, and other fields where these philosophical shifts have made an impact. At its core, this work raises fundamental questions about how we understand and study the past. The book stands as both a defense of traditional historical scholarship and a warning about forces that could undermine our ability to learn from history.

Readers view this as a critique of postmodernist approaches to historical study. Reviews indicate the book resonates with those concerned about relativism in academic history. Likes: - Clear explanations of complex theoretical concepts - Detailed analysis of specific historical case studies - Strong defense of empirical historical methods - Thorough documentation and citations - Writing style makes academic debates accessible Dislikes: - Some readers found the tone confrontational - Critics say it oversimplifies postmodernist arguments - Several note it becomes repetitive in later chapters - Some view it as too focused on Australian examples Ratings: Goodreads: 4.0/5 (42 ratings) Amazon: 4.3/5 (28 ratings) Sample review: "Provides a much-needed defense of historical truth against relativism, though the author could have been more charitable to his opponents" - Goodreads reviewer "Clear arguments but takes an unnecessarily combative stance... still valuable for understanding these debates" - Amazon reviewer

Higher Superstition by Paul R. Gross This critique examines how postmodern theories and cultural studies have influenced academic scholarship in the sciences.

Explaining Postmodernism by Stephen Hicks The book traces the philosophical evolution of postmodernism from its roots in German idealism to its current influence in academia.

The Flight from Truth by Jean-François Revel A systematic analysis of how relativism and ideological thinking have affected modern intellectual discourse.

Fashionable Nonsense by Alan Sokal The authors expose the misuse of scientific concepts by postmodern philosophers and social theorists.

Why Truth Matters by Ophelia Benson An examination of truth claims and knowledge in contemporary academic discourse and cultural criticism.

🔖 Keith Windschuttle wrote The Killing of History (1994) as a direct challenge to postmodernist theories that were becoming increasingly dominant in historical studies 📚 The book specifically critiques influential theorists like Michel Foucault, Hayden White, and Roland Barthes for their rejection of objective historical truth 🎓 Windschuttle's work sparked significant debate in Australian academic circles, particularly regarding his views on Aboriginal history and colonialism 📖 The book argues that postmodern approaches threaten to undermine the discipline of history by replacing evidence-based research with literary analysis and cultural theory 🌏 Despite being written nearly 30 years ago, many of the book's arguments about historical relativism and truth remain relevant in current debates about "post-truth" society