📖 Overview
The Case Against Hillary Clinton examines Hillary Clinton's political career through a critical lens, with a focus on her time as First Lady and her 2000 Senate campaign in New York. Journalist Peggy Noonan presents research, interviews, and analysis to construct her assessment of Clinton's character and qualifications.
The book traces Clinton's path from her early career as a lawyer through her years in Arkansas and the White House. Noonan explores key controversies and decisions during these periods, including healthcare reform efforts and various political scandals.
Noonan's investigation moves beyond surface-level politics to examine Clinton's leadership style, relationships with staff and colleagues, and approach to power. The text includes perspectives from both Clinton's critics and supporters.
The work raises questions about authenticity in modern American politics and the nature of political ambition. At its core, it grapples with tensions between public service and personal advancement in contemporary democracy.
👀 Reviews
Readers note the book's timeliness for its 2000 publication during Hillary Clinton's Senate campaign. Many describe it as a detailed examination of the Clintons' political history in Arkansas and Washington.
Positive reviews highlight:
- Clear documentation of sources
- Focus on specific policy decisions and actions
- Analysis of the Clinton administration's scandals
- Noonan's writing style and pacing
Common criticisms:
- Too much emphasis on speculation about motives
- Selective use of facts to support predetermined conclusions
- Dated content that doesn't cover later events
- Perceived partisan tone
Review Scores:
Amazon: 3.5/5 (382 reviews)
Goodreads: 3.3/5 (286 ratings)
Sample reader comments:
"Well-researched but clearly biased" - Amazon reviewer
"Stronger on Arkansas years than White House period" - Goodreads review
"Makes valid points but overreaches in conclusions" - Barnes & Noble review
📚 Similar books
Hard Choices by Hillary Rodham Clinton
A firsthand account of Clinton's time as Secretary of State provides insight into her political decisions and worldview.
Crisis of Character by Gary J. Byrne A former Secret Service officer shares his observations from working in the Clinton White House during Bill Clinton's presidency.
Clinton Cash by Peter Schweizer An investigation into the financial dealings and political relationships of Bill and Hillary Clinton after leaving the White House.
No Higher Honor by Condoleezza Rice The former Secretary of State's memoir details her experiences in the Bush administration and interactions with the Clintons.
Game Change by John Heilemann, Mark Halperin A behind-the-scenes account of the 2008 presidential campaign explores the clash between Obama and Clinton during the Democratic primaries.
Crisis of Character by Gary J. Byrne A former Secret Service officer shares his observations from working in the Clinton White House during Bill Clinton's presidency.
Clinton Cash by Peter Schweizer An investigation into the financial dealings and political relationships of Bill and Hillary Clinton after leaving the White House.
No Higher Honor by Condoleezza Rice The former Secretary of State's memoir details her experiences in the Bush administration and interactions with the Clintons.
Game Change by John Heilemann, Mark Halperin A behind-the-scenes account of the 2008 presidential campaign explores the clash between Obama and Clinton during the Democratic primaries.
🤔 Interesting facts
📚 Peggy Noonan wrote the book while working as a columnist for The Wall Street Journal, where she continues to write her weekly "Declarations" column.
🏛️ The book was published in 2000, during Hillary Clinton's successful campaign for U.S. Senate in New York, making it one of the first major critical works about her political career.
✍️ Before becoming an author and columnist, Noonan served as a speechwriter for President Ronald Reagan and wrote his famous address following the Challenger disaster.
📖 The book spent 8 weeks on The New York Times Best Seller list despite being released during a contentious election season with multiple competing political books.
🗽 A central argument of the book focuses on Clinton's decision to run for Senate in New York despite having no prior connection to the state, a move Noonan termed "carpetbagging."