Making Uzbekistan: Nation, Empire, and Revolution in the Early USSR

Making Uzbekistan examines the formation of modern Uzbek national identity during the early Soviet period of the 1920s and 1930s. The book focuses on the role of local Central Asian Muslim intellectuals who worked within Soviet structures to define and establish Uzbek nationhood. The narrative tracks the complex interactions between Jadid reformers, Soviet authorities, and various cultural-political factions in Central Asia after the Bolshevik revolution. Through extensive research in multiple languages, Khalid reconstructs the strategic decisions and ideological developments that shaped the emergence of Soviet Uzbekistan. The book explores the transformation of Turkestan from a colonial territory of the Russian Empire into the Uzbek Soviet Socialist Republic. Key topics include language reform, educational policy, gender roles, and the evolution of cultural institutions under early Soviet rule. This work challenges simplistic views of Soviet nationalities policy and reveals the active agency of local elites in nation-building processes. Through its examination of this pivotal period, the book illuminates broader questions about nationalism, modernization, and the relationship between empire and nation-state.

Readers appreciate the book's detailed research on Uzbekistan's formation through Soviet and pre-Soviet periods. Several academics note Khalid's use of primary sources in Uzbek and Russian to document the complex cultural shifts during nationalization. Positive points: - Thorough examination of Jadid reformers' role - Clear explanation of how Soviet policies shaped Uzbek identity - Strong archival evidence and documentation - Maps and photographs enhance understanding Critical feedback: - Dense academic writing style challenging for non-specialists - Some sections become repetitive - Limited coverage of ordinary citizens' perspectives - High price point noted by multiple readers Ratings: Goodreads: 4.14/5 (7 ratings) Amazon: 5/5 (2 reviews) Google Books: No ratings One academic reviewer on H-Net praised the "meticulous attention to cultural and political transformations," while a Goodreads reader noted it was "not for casual reading but worth the effort for serious students of Central Asian history."

Red Nations: The Nationalities Experience in and after the USSR by Jeremy Smith This study examines how Soviet policies shaped the formation of national identities across multiple ethnic groups in the USSR during the 20th century.

Empire of Nations: Ethnographic Knowledge and the Making of the Soviet Union by Francine Hirsch The book analyzes how ethnographers and administrators categorized and organized ethnic identities to construct the Soviet multiethnic state.

Lost Kingdom: A History of Russian Nationalism by Serhii Plokhy The text traces the evolution of Russian national identity and its relationship with surrounding territories from the medieval period through the post-Soviet era.

The Affirmative Action Empire: Nations and Nationalism in the Soviet Union by Terry Martin This work documents the Soviet Union's systematic promotion of ethnic particularism and national consciousness among its non-Russian populations.

Revolution and Identity in Central Asia: The Politics of History Making by Isabelle Kreindler The book examines how Central Asian identities were transformed through Soviet modernization programs and nation-building policies.

🔹 The book explores how Soviet policies ironically helped create a distinct Uzbek national identity, even though the USSR generally opposed nationalism 🔹 Author Adeeb Khalid is one of the few Western scholars fluent in Uzbek, Russian, and Ottoman Turkish, allowing him unique access to previously untranslated historical documents 🔹 Uzbekistan as a defined territory didn't exist before 1924 - the region was previously part of an area known as Turkestan, with fluid cultural boundaries between various Central Asian peoples 🔹 The Jadids, Muslim modernist reformers featured prominently in the book, initially opposed Soviet rule but later allied with the Bolsheviks to advance their cultural reform agenda 🔹 The process of creating modern Uzbekistan involved radical changes in writing systems - from Arabic script to Latin alphabet in 1927, then to Cyrillic in 1940, reflecting shifting political allegiances