Class Dismissed

Class Dismissed follows professor John Marsh as he investigates the relationship between higher education and economic inequality in America. His journey takes him across the country to meet with students, educators, and experts while examining data about college access and outcomes. Marsh combines personal narrative with research and reporting to question common assumptions about education's role in social mobility. He explores why many Americans believe a college degree is the key to economic success, and tests this belief against economic realities. Through interviews and analysis, the book examines both individual stories of student debt and larger systemic issues in American higher education. The narrative tracks Marsh's evolution from a true believer in education's transformative power to someone with more complex views. The book challenges the dominant narrative about higher education as an economic equalizer, suggesting that focusing solely on college access may distract from deeper structural economic problems. This work contributes to ongoing debates about education reform, income inequality, and the American Dream.

Readers found Class Dismissed presents a clear critique of higher education's role in economic mobility. Many noted its detailed research and data-driven approach, with several Amazon reviewers highlighting Marsh's analysis of income inequality statistics. Readers appreciated: - Clear writing style that makes complex economic concepts accessible - Personal anecdotes mixed with academic research - Challenge to common assumptions about education and social mobility Main criticisms: - Some found the conclusions too pessimistic - Limited discussion of potential solutions - Focus primarily on four-year degrees, less coverage of other educational paths One Goodreads reviewer wrote: "Makes a compelling case but offers little hope for change." Multiple readers noted the book works better as analysis than as a blueprint for reform. Ratings: Goodreads: 3.8/5 (42 ratings) Amazon: 4.2/5 (28 ratings) Library Thing: 3.5/5 (12 ratings)

The Great Risk Shift by Jacob S. Hacker This examination of economic instability in American life tracks how financial risks have shifted from institutions to individuals through changes in education, healthcare, and employment.

Excellent Sheep by William Deresiewicz A critique of higher education reveals how elite universities perpetuate social inequality while failing to deliver on their promises of social mobility.

The Student Loan Scam by Alan Collinge This investigation exposes the mechanisms behind the student loan industry and its impact on social mobility in America.

Lower Ed by Tressie McMillan Cottom An analysis of for-profit colleges demonstrates how these institutions capitalize on economic inequality and perpetuate social stratification.

The Tyranny of Merit by Michael J. Sandel A study of meritocracy in education and society explains how the promise of upward mobility through education has contributed to social division and political dysfunction.

🎓 John Marsh was inspired to write this book while teaching at a community college, where he witnessed firsthand the struggles of students trying to improve their economic situation through education. 📚 The book challenges the popular notion that higher education is the solution to economic inequality, drawing on both historical data and contemporary research. 💡 Marsh points out that in 1971, only 11% of taxi drivers had college degrees, but by 2010, this number had risen to 15% - highlighting the issue of "degree inflation." 🏫 The author argues that the U.S. already produces more college graduates than the job market can absorb, with about 30% of college graduates working in jobs that don't require degrees. 💰 Despite criticizing the "education as salvation" narrative, Marsh acknowledges that college graduates still earn approximately 84% more over their lifetimes than those with only a high school diploma.