Circle of Six

Circle of Six chronicles the investigation into the 1972 murder of NYPD Patrolman Phillip Cardillo at a Nation of Islam mosque in Harlem. Written by Detective Randy Jurgensen, who worked the case for decades, the book provides a first-hand account of one of the most controversial police cases in New York City history. The narrative follows Jurgensen's relentless pursuit of justice, documenting the political tensions, departmental conflicts, and community unrest that complicated the investigation. The authors detail the initial police response, subsequent investigation, and the ripple effects that impacted law enforcement and community relations in New York. Through interviews, police records, and personal recollections, the book reconstructs both the crime and its aftermath. It examines the roles of various figures including police officials, politicians, community leaders, and witnesses who shaped the course of events. The book serves as both a police procedural and a study of how institutional politics can influence criminal investigations. At its core, it raises questions about justice, accountability, and the complex relationship between law enforcement and the communities they serve.

Readers describe this as a raw, firsthand account of the NYPD investigation into Officer Phillip Cardillo's 1972 murder at a Harlem mosque. Many note its detailed portrayal of police work and department politics in 1970s New York. Readers appreciated: - Insider perspective from detective Jurgensen who worked the case - Documentation of departmental and political interference - Historical context of police-community tensions - Clear explanation of complex events Main criticisms: - Writing can be repetitive - Some sections feel disorganized - Political commentary detracts from the core story Ratings: Amazon: 4.4/5 from 121 reviews Goodreads: 3.9/5 from 98 ratings Several readers mentioned being angered by the case's outcome and handling by NYPD leadership. One reviewer noted: "It reads like you're sitting with veteran cops hearing war stories." Multiple reviews highlighted how the book reveals systemic issues between law enforcement, politics, and community relations that remain relevant today.

Blue Blood by Edward Conlon A NYPD detective's memoir chronicles his career from beat cop to detective, exposing the realities of police work in New York City during the 1990s.

Prince of the City by Robert Daley The true story of NYPD narcotics detective Robert Leuci exposes corruption within the department during the 1970s through his role as a whistleblower.

Serpico by Peter Maas The account of Frank Serpico's fight against police corruption in the NYPD reveals the cost of breaking the blue wall of silence.

Rising Through the Ranks by Jon Coppola A retired NYPD detective shares his experiences investigating homicides in Brooklyn during the high-crime decades of the 1980s and 1990s.

Street Warrior by Ralph Friedman, Patrick Picciarelli The memoir of the NYPD's most decorated detective from the Bronx details his career making over 2,000 arrests in the 1970s.

🚔 The book details the investigation of NYPD Officer Philip Cardillo's murder in 1972 at a Nation of Islam mosque in Harlem, a case that remained officially unsolved for 40 years. 🏆 Author Randy Jurgensen served 21 years with the NYPD and received over 200 departmental awards, including Combat Cross and Medal of Honor. 📽️ The events described in the book inspired the 1981 film "Fort Apache, The Bronx" starring Paul Newman, in which Jurgensen served as technical advisor. ⚖️ The case exposed deep political tensions between the NYPD, the Nation of Islam, and Mayor John Lindsay's administration, leading to significant changes in police protocol for handling situations in religious buildings. 🔍 Co-author Robert Cea worked as an NYPD detective in Brooklyn North Narcotics and later became a successful true crime writer, bringing firsthand experience to the narrative.