Breaking Their Will: Shedding Light on Religious Child Maltreatment

Breaking Their Will examines religious child maltreatment across multiple faiths and denominations in the United States. Author Janet Heimlich investigates cases where religious beliefs and practices have led to physical abuse, emotional trauma, medical neglect, and sexual exploitation of children. The book combines research, interviews, and case studies to document how religious doctrines can enable or justify child abuse. Heimlich explores the role of authoritarian religious cultures, literal interpretations of texts, and isolation from secular society in perpetuating maltreatment. The investigation spans mainstream and fringe religious groups, examining patterns of abuse and factors that allow it to continue. The text includes perspectives from survivors, religious scholars, mental health professionals, and child protection advocates. This work raises questions about the intersection of religious freedom and child welfare in American society. The analysis challenges readers to consider how faith communities can maintain their beliefs while ensuring the protection of their youngest members.

Readers describe this as a well-researched examination of child abuse in religious contexts, backed by case studies and expert interviews. The book's systematic approach to categorizing different types of religious maltreatment resonated with many survivors. Readers appreciated: - Clear organization and accessible writing style - Balanced treatment of different faiths - Practical recommendations for prevention - Extensive source documentation Common criticisms: - Some found it emotionally difficult to read - A few readers wanted more focus on solutions - Several noted it could have covered more non-Western religions Ratings: Goodreads: 4.2/5 (196 ratings) Amazon: 4.5/5 (89 reviews) Notable reader comment: "Finally, someone has done the research and connected the dots between authoritarian religion and child abuse" - Amazon reviewer Another reader noted: "Important topic but hard to get through due to disturbing content" - Goodreads review

God's Perfect Child: Living and Dying in the Christian Science Church by Caroline Fraser Documents the impact of Christian Science beliefs on children's medical care and wellbeing through historical records and firsthand accounts.

Children of Paradise: The Religious Visions and Dreams of Paradise by American Children by Donald Ratcliff Examines children's experiences in religious environments through case studies and psychological research.

To Train Up A Child by Michael Pearl and Debi Pearl Studies the controversies and consequences of religious-based discipline methods on child development.

Violent Religious Groups and Child Abuse by Susan J. Palmer Presents research on child welfare in religious movements through interviews and investigation records.

Not in God's Name: Confronting Religious Violence by Jonathan Sacks Analyzes the intersection of religious beliefs and child-rearing practices across different faith traditions and communities.

📚 The author Janet Heimlich was inspired to write this book after learning about the death of Sean Paddock, a four-year-old who was suffocated by his adoptive mother for religious reasons. 🔍 The book introduces the concept of "religious authoritarian culture" and identifies three main characteristics: fear or paranoia, isolation, and superiority complex. 📖 Breaking Their Will was the first mainstream book to comprehensively examine child abuse and neglect enabled by religious beliefs in the United States. ⚖️ The research covers various faiths including Christianity, Judaism, Islam, and fringe religious movements, examining how different belief systems can sometimes be used to justify or enable child maltreatment. 🏆 The book received the 2012 Silver Winner Award in the Religion Category from Independent Publisher Book Awards (IPPY Awards).