The Man-Eating Myth

The Man-Eating Myth challenges accepted anthropological accounts of cannibalism across human cultures. Arens examines historical and ethnographic evidence of cannibalism, questioning the reliability of widely-cited reports. Through case studies spanning multiple continents and time periods, the book analyzes documents, testimonies, and research methods used to establish claims of ritualistic human consumption. The text focuses on how these accounts originated and spread through academic and popular literature. Arens investigates the role of cultural bias and colonial perspectives in shaping Western understanding of cannibalism. His research includes examination of reports from explorers, missionaries, and anthropologists who documented supposed cannibalistic practices. The book raises fundamental questions about how societies perceive and document the customs of other cultures. It examines the intersection of academic authority, cultural assumptions, and the creation of enduring myths about human behavior.

Readers value Arens' skepticism toward historical accounts of cannibalism and his examination of how these stories often reflect colonial prejudices. Many reviewers note the book made them question accepted anthropological claims and think critically about cultural biases in research. Readers praise: - Clear writing style and logical arguments - Extensive source analysis - Challenge to academic assumptions Common criticisms: - Some find Arens too dismissive of all cannibalism evidence - Limited examination of ritual cannibalism - Perceived overemphasis on colonial narratives Ratings: Goodreads: 3.9/5 (43 ratings) Amazon: 4.1/5 (11 ratings) Sample reader comment: "Forces us to examine how we accept certain 'facts' about other cultures without questioning the origins of those claims" - Goodreads reviewer Critical comment: "Makes valid points about colonial bias but goes too far in denying any historical instances of cannibalism" - Amazon reviewer

The Invention of Cannibalism by Cristina Santos An anthropological examination of how European colonizers created and perpetuated myths of cannibalism to justify conquest and cultural superiority.

Cannibal Talk by Gananath Obeyesekere A critical analysis of historical accounts of cannibalism in the Pacific Islands, revealing the role of colonial prejudices in shaping these narratives.

Gods of the Upper Air by Charles King The story of Franz Boas and his students who challenged pseudoscientific racism and cultural prejudices in early anthropology.

The Death of Luigi Trastulli by Alessandro Portelli A methodological study of oral history that examines how societies create and maintain collective myths and memories.

Noble Savages by Napoleon Chagnon A firsthand account by an anthropologist that questions romanticized myths about indigenous peoples and challenges anthropological assumptions.

🔍 Arens examined over 100 years of anthropological literature and found no credible firsthand accounts of ritual cannibalism as a cultural practice. 🌍 The book sparked intense controversy in anthropological circles when published in 1979, challenging long-held beliefs about cannibalism in "primitive" societies. 📚 Many cases of reported cannibalism that Arens investigated turned out to be based on colonial propaganda, used to justify the subjugation of indigenous peoples. 🎓 While teaching at Stony Brook University, Arens initially became skeptical of cannibalism claims when he couldn't find solid evidence for his anthropology lectures. 🗣️ The Aztecs, often cited as practitioners of ritual cannibalism, may have been misrepresented by Spanish conquistadors who used these claims to justify their conquest - a key example explored in the book.