Beyond Hindu and Muslim

Beyond Hindu and Muslim examines religious identity and communal relations in two villages in northern India's Bihar state. Through ethnographic research and historical analysis, Gottschalk investigates how religious categories interact with other social identities in everyday village life. The book combines archival research, oral histories, and on-the-ground observations to trace changes in Hindu-Muslim relations from the colonial period through modern times. Gottschalk documents how villagers navigate multiple, overlapping identities including religion, caste, class, and regional affiliations. Field observations and interviews reveal the complex ways religious identity manifests in routine social interactions, economic relationships, and spatial arrangements within the villages. The analysis covers both moments of conflict and everyday cooperation between Hindu and Muslim residents. The work challenges simplistic binary frameworks of religious identity in South Asia, demonstrating how lived experiences often transcend rigid categorizations. Through its granular focus on village life, the book offers insights into broader questions about religious pluralism, identity formation, and communal relations in contemporary India.

Based on available online reviews, readers value Gottschalk's focus on local village life and religious identities in India, rather than relying on broad national narratives. Multiple reviewers noted the book offers insights into how religious identity intersects with daily village interactions. Readers highlighted: - Detailed ethnographic research and fieldwork - Examination of how colonialism impacted religious categories - Clear writing style that remains accessible despite academic content Common criticisms: - Limited scope focusing on only one village - Some found the theoretical framework too dense - Price point too high for wider readership Ratings: Goodreads: 4.0/5 (7 ratings) Google Books: No ratings available Amazon: No customer reviews available One academic reviewer on Goodreads wrote: "The book succeeds in showing how religious identity operates differently at local levels versus national discourse." Note: This book has limited public reviews online due to its academic nature.

Religious Nationalism: Hindus and Muslims in India by Peter van der Veer Examines how religious identities in India have been shaped by colonial encounters and nationalist politics through anthropological and historical analysis.

Ethnic and Religious Violence in Indonesia by Jacques Bertrand Explores the intersection of religious identity, communal relations, and political power through case studies across Indonesian communities.

The Production of Hindu-Muslim Violence in Contemporary India by Paul R. Brass Investigates the institutional mechanisms and political processes that contribute to religious violence in modern India.

Muslims in Indian Cities: Trajectories of Marginalisation by Laurent Gayer and Christophe Jaffrelot Maps the social, economic, and spatial dynamics of Muslim communities across multiple Indian urban centers through empirical research.

The Language of Secular Islam by Kavita Saraswathi Datla Chronicles the development of Muslim intellectual thought and educational institutions in early twentieth-century Hyderabad State.

🔹 Peter Gottschalk conducted his field research in "Arampur," a pseudonymous village in Bihar, India, where he lived for 18 months to study Hindu-Muslim relations at the grassroots level. 🔹 The book challenges the colonial British categorization of Indians as primarily defined by their religious identities, showing how local villagers often identify more strongly with caste, occupation, or locality than religion. 🔹 The author uses historical maps as analytical tools to demonstrate how British colonials imposed religious categories on Indian landscapes that previously had more fluid social boundaries. 🔹 Bihar, where the study takes place, was once home to ancient Buddhist universities like Nalanda and Vikramshila, though today it's primarily known for Hindu-Muslim demographics. 🔹 The research reveals that village residents often share sacred spaces and participate in each other's festivals, demonstrating religious coexistence that contradicts the dominant narrative of Hindu-Muslim conflict.