📖 Overview
Some Secrets Should Never Be Kept is a picture book that addresses body safety and protective behaviors for children ages 3-12. Set in a medieval castle, it follows the story of Sir Alfred, a young boy who lives with his mother, a servant to Lord Henry.
The narrative focuses on Sir Alfred's experience with an adult who makes him uncomfortable through inappropriate touching. Through the story's progression, Sir Alfred learns about the importance of telling trusted adults when something doesn't feel right.
Written by Jayneen Sanders and illustrated by Craig Smith, the book uses age-appropriate language and imagery to communicate serious safety concepts. The medieval setting provides a familiar fairy-tale framework for young readers to engage with the material.
This educational resource serves as a tool for parents, caregivers, and educators to initiate conversations about personal safety and the distinction between safe and unsafe secrets. The story reinforces the message that children have the right to feel safe and speak up about their concerns.
👀 Reviews
Parents and educators value this book as a tool for teaching children about body safety and inappropriate touching. Readers note it handles sensitive content in an age-appropriate way without being scary.
Positives from reviews:
- Clear, simple language children understand
- Opens dialogue between parents and kids
- Includes discussion questions and teaching points
- Illustrations support the message
Common criticisms:
- Some find it too direct for young children
- A few parents say it caused anxiety in their kids
- Price point considered high for length
Ratings across platforms:
Goodreads: 4.3/5 (537 ratings)
Amazon: 4.6/5 (1,246 ratings)
Notable reader comment: "This book gave my daughter and me the vocabulary to discuss body safety in a natural way" - Amazon reviewer
Critical review: "The message is important but the delivery is heavy-handed. There are gentler ways to approach this topic." - Goodreads reviewer
📚 Similar books
My Body Belongs to Me by Jill Starishevsky
This illustrated book teaches children about personal boundaries and body safety through a story about a child who tells a trusted adult about an uncomfortable touch.
Miles Is the Boss of His Body by Samantha Kurtzman-Counter, Abbie Schiller The story follows Miles learning to speak up about his body boundaries through everyday situations with family and friends.
I Said No! by Kimberly King, Zack King This straightforward safety guide provides children with scenarios and tools for recognizing unsafe situations and responding to unwanted touches.
Your Body Belongs to You by Cornelia Maude Spelman The book presents body autonomy concepts through simple examples of children setting boundaries in daily interactions.
Not in Room 204 by Shannon Riggs The narrative follows a teacher who creates a safe space for her students to speak up about secrets that make them uncomfortable.
Miles Is the Boss of His Body by Samantha Kurtzman-Counter, Abbie Schiller The story follows Miles learning to speak up about his body boundaries through everyday situations with family and friends.
I Said No! by Kimberly King, Zack King This straightforward safety guide provides children with scenarios and tools for recognizing unsafe situations and responding to unwanted touches.
Your Body Belongs to You by Cornelia Maude Spelman The book presents body autonomy concepts through simple examples of children setting boundaries in daily interactions.
Not in Room 204 by Shannon Riggs The narrative follows a teacher who creates a safe space for her students to speak up about secrets that make them uncomfortable.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔹 Author Jayneen Sanders wrote this book after discovering there were very few children's resources addressing body safety in a non-threatening way.
🔹 The book has been translated into multiple languages and is used by child protection organizations worldwide as an educational tool.
🔹 The story uses medieval characters and setting to create emotional distance while discussing sensitive topics, making it more approachable for young readers.
🔹 Following the book's success, Sanders developed a teacher's resource pack and started conducting workshops for educators and parents about child protection.
🔹 The story was specifically written to be gender-neutral in its messaging, ensuring its relevance for all children, though the main character is a boy named Sir Alfred.