The Butcher

The Butcher chronicles the true story of Tommy Pitera, a New York mafia killer who operated during the 1980s and early 1990s. Carlo reconstructs Pitera's journey from martial arts student to Bonanno crime family member through extensive research and interviews. The book details Pitera's double life - functioning as both a calculated mob enforcer and a seemingly ordinary citizen who lived with his parents in Brooklyn. FBI investigations and law enforcement efforts to build a case against Pitera form a central part of the narrative. Drawing from court records, witness accounts, and conversations with investigators, Carlo presents a complete portrait of one of the most prolific killers in American mafia history. The investigation and eventual prosecution of Pitera reveals the complex workings of organized crime and law enforcement in New York during this period. The narrative examines questions about the nature of violence and duality in human behavior, while documenting a significant chapter in American crime history. This account goes beyond typical mob stories to explore the psychology of its subject.

Readers found the book detailed but disturbing in its portrayal of serial killer Tommy Lynn Sells. Many noted it brought attention to law enforcement failures and systemic issues that allowed Sells to continue killing. Liked: - Thorough research and interviews - Clear timeline of events - Focus on victims' stories - Examination of Sells' psychology Disliked: - Graphic violence descriptions felt excessive - Writing style called "repetitive" by multiple reviewers - Some fact-checking errors noted by readers familiar with cases - Several reviewers felt uncomfortable with Sells receiving too much attention Ratings: Goodreads: 3.7/5 (1,100+ ratings) Amazon: 4.1/5 (200+ ratings) "Too much focus on glorifying the killer" - Goodreads reviewer "Important but hard to read due to content" - Amazon reviewer "Could have been shorter without losing impact" - Barnes & Noble review "Does justice to victims while exposing systemic failures" - LibraryThing review

The Iceman by Philip Carlo Chronicles Richard Kuklinski's life as a brutal contract killer who led a double life as a family man while carrying out over 100 murders for organized crime.

The Night Stalker by Philip Carlo Details the crimes and capture of Richard Ramirez, who terrorized California with a series of home invasions, murders, and sexual assaults in the 1980s.

The Killer Inside Me by Jim Thompson Follows a small-town deputy sheriff who maintains a perfect reputation while secretly being a methodical murderer.

The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson Weaves together the stories of the 1893 Chicago World's Fair and H.H. Holmes, who used his hotel to lure and murder dozens of victims.

Green River, Running Red by Ann Rule Chronicles the Green River Killer's two-decade murder spree and the investigation that finally brought Gary Ridgway to justice.

🔪 The book's subject, Tommy "Karate" Pitera, earned his nickname from his expertise in martial arts, having studied karate in Japan where he earned multiple black belts. 📖 Author Philip Carlo conducted over 250 hours of personal interviews with Tommy Pitera while he was incarcerated to gather material for the book. 💀 Pitera was known for his high-pitched voice, which starkly contrasted with his brutal reputation, and he would often speak to his victims in a falsetto tone before killing them. 🗃️ Unlike most mafia members, Pitera kept detailed records of his crimes in notebooks, including maps to burial locations, which later helped authorities locate several bodies. 🎭 Despite his ruthless nature as a killer, Pitera was also known to be a talented artist and would often draw intricate sketches of martial arts positions and Japanese imagery during his free time.