Book
George vs. George: The American Revolution as Seen from Both Sides
by Rosalyn Schanzer
📖 Overview
George vs. George presents parallel portraits of King George III of Britain and George Washington during the American Revolution. The book examines their backgrounds, beliefs, and roles as leaders on opposing sides of the conflict.
Through illustrations and historical accounts, the narrative moves between both perspectives to explore how each George viewed the brewing revolution. The text incorporates primary sources including letters, documents, and quotes from key figures involved in the events.
The book documents the progression of tensions between Britain and the American colonies, examining military strategies and pivotal moments that shaped the war. Details about daily life, cultural context, and the political climate help frame the central conflict.
This balanced approach to Revolutionary War history demonstrates how perspective shapes our understanding of historical events. The dual viewpoint structure invites readers to consider questions about loyalty, justice, and how opposing sides can each believe they are fighting for what is right.
👀 Reviews
Readers note this book presents a balanced, neutral examination of both American and British perspectives during the Revolutionary War. Parents and teachers praise its use of primary sources, period illustrations, and side-by-side comparisons that help students understand complex viewpoints.
Likes:
- Clear organization and visual presentation
- Accessible for ages 8-14
- Explains motivations of both sides without bias
- Includes maps, quotes, and historical artwork
Dislikes:
- Some found it oversimplified for older students
- A few readers wanted more detail on specific battles
- Limited coverage of perspectives beyond George Washington and King George III
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.1/5 (440 ratings)
Amazon: 4.7/5 (156 ratings)
Notable Review: "This book helped my students grasp that history isn't black and white. The parallel structure comparing both Georges' viewpoints made complex concepts digestible for middle schoolers." - 5th grade teacher on Amazon
📚 Similar books
Two Flags, One Revolution by Stanley Weintraub
A dual-perspective history of the American Revolution told through British and Continental army soldiers' experiences and accounts.
Crossing the Delaware: Perspectives on the American Revolution by David Hackett Fischer The American Revolution unfolds through multiple viewpoints including Native Americans, free blacks, loyalists, and patriots.
Liberty's Daughters and Sons by Mary Beth Norton The Revolutionary War period comes to life through letters, diaries, and documents from both British and Colonial children and teenagers.
A Tale of Two Generals by Charles Flood The parallel stories of George Washington and British General William Howe reveal the strategic decisions that shaped the Revolutionary War's outcome.
Voices of 1776 by Richard Wheeler First-hand accounts from soldiers, civilians, and leaders on both sides create a comprehensive picture of life during the American Revolution.
Crossing the Delaware: Perspectives on the American Revolution by David Hackett Fischer The American Revolution unfolds through multiple viewpoints including Native Americans, free blacks, loyalists, and patriots.
Liberty's Daughters and Sons by Mary Beth Norton The Revolutionary War period comes to life through letters, diaries, and documents from both British and Colonial children and teenagers.
A Tale of Two Generals by Charles Flood The parallel stories of George Washington and British General William Howe reveal the strategic decisions that shaped the Revolutionary War's outcome.
Voices of 1776 by Richard Wheeler First-hand accounts from soldiers, civilians, and leaders on both sides create a comprehensive picture of life during the American Revolution.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔷 Both King George III and George Washington were exceptionally tall for their time - Washington stood at 6'2" and King George at 6'0" when the average height for men was about 5'5".
🔷 Author Rosalyn Schanzer created all the illustrations in the book using a scratchboard technique, where she scratched away black ink to reveal white lines underneath, creating detailed period-accurate artwork.
🔷 Despite being portrayed as a tyrant in American history, King George III was known in Britain as "Farmer George" for his interest in agriculture and was the first Hanoverian monarch to study science and speak English as his first language.
🔷 The book points out that both sides used propaganda during the war - the British portrayed American rebels as violent thugs, while Americans depicted the British as cruel oppressors, showing how perspective shapes historical narratives.
🔷 At the time of the American Revolution, only about one-third of colonists actively supported independence, while another third remained loyal to Britain, and the final third tried to remain neutral.