A Shameful Act

A Shameful Act examines the Armenian Genocide of 1915 through extensive research of Ottoman and European archives. The book traces the historical context and events leading up to the mass deportation and killing of Armenians during World War I. Through official documents, testimonies, and correspondence, Taner Akçam reconstructs the Ottoman government's decision-making process and implementation of policies against the Armenian population. The text provides analysis of international responses and the role of Germany, while also examining internal Ottoman politics and military considerations. The work investigates the aftermath of the genocide, including attempts at prosecution and the ongoing debate over recognition. Akçam presents demographic data and official records to establish the scope and systematic nature of the events. This scholarly examination raises questions about collective memory, national identity, and the challenges of confronting historical atrocities. The book stands as a contribution to the study of state violence and mechanisms of denial.

Readers value the detailed research and extensive documentation Akçam provides through Ottoman archives and historical records. Multiple reviewers note the book presents clear evidence while maintaining academic rigor. What readers liked: - Clear chronological organization of events - Translation quality from Turkish to English - Inclusion of primary source documents - Balanced examination of different historical perspectives What readers disliked: - Dense academic writing style - Frequent use of untranslated Turkish terms - Complex political context requires background knowledge - Some sections become repetitive Review Ratings: Goodreads: 4.3/5 (127 ratings) Amazon: 4.4/5 (41 ratings) Notable reader comments: "Meticulously researched but challenging for general readers" - Goodreads reviewer "Would benefit from more maps and visual aids" - Amazon reviewer "Important historical document though writing is dry" - Amazon reviewer

Black Dog of Fate by Peter Balakian A memoir weaves personal history with the Armenian genocide's impact through three generations of an American-Armenian family.

They Can Live in the Desert but Nowhere Else by Ronald Grigor Suny A comprehensive examination of the Armenian genocide draws from Ottoman archives to present causes, implementation, and consequences.

The Burning Tigris by Peter Balakian A documentation of the Armenian genocide connects the events to international responses and American humanitarian efforts during the period.

The Great Fire by Lou Ureneck A narrative chronicles the 1922 destruction of Smyrna and the rescue mission that saved thousands of Christians from death.

Paradise Lost by Giles Milton A reconstruction of Smyrna's final days presents multiple perspectives from survivors and witnesses of the city's destruction in 1922.

🔹 Author Taner Akçam was the first Turkish scholar to openly acknowledge and discuss the Armenian Genocide, facing significant personal and professional risks for doing so, including self-exile from Turkey. 🔹 The book's title "A Shameful Act" comes from a quote by Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, the founder of modern Turkey, who in 1920 referred to the Armenian massacres as "a shameful act of the past." 🔹 Much of the research for this book was conducted using previously untapped Ottoman archives and documents, providing new primary source evidence about the genocide's systematic nature. 🔹 Akçam discovered that Ottoman officials used a sophisticated coding system in their telegrams to disguise orders related to Armenian deportations and killings, which he helped decode for this work. 🔹 The author faced death threats and legal persecution under Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code, which makes it illegal to "insult Turkishness," due to his research and publications on this topic.