📖 Overview
A dark psychological thriller centered on Ambrosia Wellington, who reluctantly returns to Wesleyan University for her 10-year college reunion. Upon arrival, she receives anonymous notes referencing something terrible that happened during her freshman year - events she has worked hard to forget and move past.
The narrative alternates between present-day Amb at the reunion and her freshman year in 2007, gradually revealing the toxic friendship between Amb and her former best friend Sloane Sullivan. The story explores how Amb transformed from an insecure freshman desperate to fit in to someone capable of participating in increasingly dangerous behavior.
Through dual timelines, the book examines the pressures of college life, female friendships, and the lengths some will go to achieve social status. The story raises questions about redemption, accountability, and whether people can truly change after committing terrible acts.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe this as a dark, mean-girls thriller that delivers intense psychological suspense but may be too cruel for some tastes.
Readers appreciate:
- Raw, unflinching portrayal of toxic female friendships
- Strong pacing between past and present timelines
- Authentic depiction of college dynamics
- Unpredictable twists in the final act
Common criticisms:
- Characters are uniformly unlikeable and hard to connect with
- Violence and cruelty feel gratuitous
- Some plot points strain credibility
- The ending left many readers unsatisfied
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.7/5 (52,000+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.1/5 (2,800+ ratings)
Book of the Month: 3.9/5
Reader quotes:
"Couldn't put it down but felt dirty after reading it" - Goodreads reviewer
"Like Mean Girls meets Gone Girl" - Amazon reviewer
"The toxic friendship aspect rang true but the murder plot went too far" - StoryGraph reviewer
📚 Similar books
The Secret History by Donna Tartt
A group of elite college students becomes entangled in murder and deception at an exclusive New England university.
Bunny by Mona Awad An MFA student infiltrates a clique of wealthy classmates who harbor dark secrets and participate in mysterious rituals.
Catherine House by Elisabeth Thomas Students at a selective residential school face manipulation and hidden dangers while isolated from the outside world.
Social Creature by Tara Isabella Burton A young woman's obsession with her glamorous friend leads to identity theft, lies, and murder in New York City.
They Never Learn by Layne Fargo A female professor at a college campus systematically eliminates predatory men while keeping her own deadly secrets.
Bunny by Mona Awad An MFA student infiltrates a clique of wealthy classmates who harbor dark secrets and participate in mysterious rituals.
Catherine House by Elisabeth Thomas Students at a selective residential school face manipulation and hidden dangers while isolated from the outside world.
Social Creature by Tara Isabella Burton A young woman's obsession with her glamorous friend leads to identity theft, lies, and murder in New York City.
They Never Learn by Layne Fargo A female professor at a college campus systematically eliminates predatory men while keeping her own deadly secrets.
🤔 Interesting facts
🎓 The author, Laurie Elizabeth Flynn, was inspired to write this book after reflecting on her own college experiences and the complex dynamics of female friendships.
💭 Though fictional, the novel explores real psychological concepts like "relational aggression" - a form of bullying more common among young women that involves manipulation and social exclusion.
📚 The book was published in multiple countries under different titles - in the UK, it was released as "All My Darkest Impulses."
🎬 The television rights to "The Girls Are All So Nice Here" were acquired by AMC Studios for development into a series.
🖊️ Flynn wrote the first draft of this novel during National Novel Writing Month (NaNoWriMo), completing the initial manuscript in just 30 days.