Choice and Coercion

Choice and Coercion examines reproductive rights and public health policies in North Carolina during the twentieth century. The book focuses on birth control, sterilization programs, and abortion access from the 1920s through the 1970s. Through extensive archival research and personal accounts, Schoen documents how race, class, and gender shaped reproductive healthcare decisions and policies. The narrative tracks the experiences of women who sought reproductive care, along with the actions of healthcare workers, social workers, and government officials who controlled access to these services. The book analyzes North Carolina's eugenics program and state-sponsored sterilization initiatives alongside the emergence of birth control clinics and abortion reform. Each chapter presents specific cases and policy developments that occurred across different decades and regions of the state. This history reveals the complex tensions between reproductive freedom and institutional control, raising fundamental questions about bodily autonomy, medical ethics, and the role of the state in personal healthcare decisions. The work continues to resonate with contemporary debates about reproductive rights and healthcare access.

Readers credit the book for detailed research and balanced examination of reproductive rights in North Carolina, particularly noting Schoen's thorough use of historical records and personal accounts. Positive reviews highlight: - Clear documentation of sterilization programs and birth control initiatives - Integration of individual stories with broader policy analysis - Nuanced treatment of race and class dynamics Critical feedback focuses on: - Dense academic writing style that can be difficult to follow - Limited geographic scope focusing mainly on North Carolina - Some repetition in examples and arguments Ratings: Goodreads: 4.0/5 (26 ratings) Amazon: 4.4/5 (6 ratings) One academic reviewer noted: "Schoen avoids simplistic victim narratives while exposing systematic inequalities." Another reader commented: "The archival research is impressive but the prose could be more accessible." Reviews appear primarily in academic journals and scholarly platforms, with fewer general reader reviews available online.

The Birth of the Pill by Jonathan Eig This history chronicles the development of oral contraception in America through the intersecting stories of activists, scientists, and medical professionals who faced legal and social opposition.

Fit to Be Tied by Rebecca M. Kluchin The book examines sterilization practices in American hospitals between 1950-1980, revealing the different treatment of white middle-class women and women of color.

Killing the Black Body by Dorothy Roberts This work traces the history of reproductive rights in America with focus on race-based policies and their impact on Black women's bodily autonomy.

The Story of Jane by Laura Kaplan This account documents the underground abortion network that operated in Chicago from 1969 to 1973, showing how women organized to provide illegal but safe abortions.

Bodies of Knowledge by Wendy Kline The book examines the women's health movement of the 1970s through the lens of medical institutions, patient rights, and feminist activism.

🔍 Birth control advocate Margaret Sanger visited North Carolina in 1938 to support the state's eugenics program, showing how reproductive rights and eugenics were often intertwined in early 20th century America. 🏥 Between 1929 and 1975, North Carolina sterilized approximately 7,600 people through its eugenics program, with African American women being disproportionately targeted. 📚 Author Johanna Schoen was instrumental in opening North Carolina's eugenics records to the public, leading to the state's 2013 decision to compensate sterilization victims. ⚖️ The book reveals how poor women often strategically used state-funded sterilization programs to gain access to desired reproductive surgeries they couldn't otherwise afford. 🗂️ The research draws from more than 8,000 patient records and numerous personal interviews, making it one of the most comprehensive studies of state-sponsored reproductive programs in the American South.