📖 Overview
Arfy is a stray dog who writes letters to the residents of Butternut Street in hopes of finding a home. He sends notes to different houses explaining why he would make a good pet, but his efforts meet with various responses from the neighbors.
The story is told through Arfy's letters and the replies he receives. The correspondence format allows readers to see both Arfy's persistent optimism and the range of reactions from potential owners.
This picture book combines elements of letter-writing with the universal themes of belonging and persistence. Through Arfy's journey, young readers encounter an authentic portrayal of hope, determination, and the search for connection.
👀 Reviews
Readers connect emotionally with this story about a homeless dog writing letters to find a forever home. Parents and teachers report the book creates meaningful discussions with children about adoption, persistence, and compassion.
Readers appreciate:
- The letter-writing format makes the story engaging
- Illustrations convey the dog's changing emotions
- Message about not giving up hope
- Length works well for reading aloud
Common criticisms:
- Some find the ending predictable
- A few note the letter-writing premise may confuse very young children
Ratings across platforms:
Goodreads: 4.3/5 (2,800+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.8/5 (2,100+ ratings)
Barnes & Noble: 4.8/5 (100+ ratings)
"My kids ask to read this every night and take turns being different characters," notes one Amazon reviewer. A teacher on Goodreads says: "Students relate to Arfy's determination and the book opens up conversations about helping others in our community."
📚 Similar books
Found by Jeff Newman, Larry Day
A lonely sock at a laundromat searches for its match through a series of notes left around the building.
The Day the Dog Dressed Like Dad by Tom Amico and James Proimos A family dog puts on Dad's clothes and attempts to take over his daily responsibilities while Dad is away.
May I Please Have a Cookie? by Jennifer E. Morris An elephant named Alfie writes letters and tries different strategies to obtain cookies from a cookie jar.
Dear Dragon by Josh Funk Two pen pals exchange letters without realizing one is a boy and one is a dragon.
Click, Clack, Mail: A Letter to the Farm by Doreen Cronin and Betsy Lewin Farm animals engage in a letter-writing campaign to Farmer Brown to request improvements to their living conditions.
The Day the Dog Dressed Like Dad by Tom Amico and James Proimos A family dog puts on Dad's clothes and attempts to take over his daily responsibilities while Dad is away.
May I Please Have a Cookie? by Jennifer E. Morris An elephant named Alfie writes letters and tries different strategies to obtain cookies from a cookie jar.
Dear Dragon by Josh Funk Two pen pals exchange letters without realizing one is a boy and one is a dragon.
Click, Clack, Mail: A Letter to the Farm by Doreen Cronin and Betsy Lewin Farm animals engage in a letter-writing campaign to Farmer Brown to request improvements to their living conditions.
🤔 Interesting facts
🐾 Like the book's main character Arfy, nearly 3.1 million shelter dogs find forever homes each year in the United States.
📝 Author Troy Cummings has illustrated more than 40 children's books and written over 20 of them, making Arfy's story one of many beloved tales in his portfolio.
🏆 Can I Be Your Dog? earned a spot on the 2019-2020 Texas Bluebonnet Award Master List, an honor voted on by young readers across Texas.
📬 The story's format—written as a series of letters—reflects a long literary tradition called "epistolary storytelling," making complex storytelling accessible to young readers.
🐕 The book addresses the real issue of pet homelessness while maintaining an optimistic tone, leading several animal shelters to use it in their educational programs.