Making the Saints

Making the Saints explores the complex process through which historical figures have been transformed into religious icons in American culture. The book investigates multiple case studies of individuals who underwent posthumous elevation to near-sainthood status through both formal and informal channels. Moore traces how these figures' legacies evolved through different eras of American history, examining the role of both religious institutions and popular culture in shaping their mythologies. The analysis covers the specific mechanisms and social forces that enable ordinary people to be recast as extraordinary spiritual exemplars. This work examines how Americans reconcile their professed separation of church and state with their enduring need for spiritual heroes. By studying the saint-making process in a nominally secular society, Moore reveals insights into how sacred meaning and religious identity persist in modern American life.

According to reader reviews, Making the Saints offers academic depth but lacks readability for general audiences. Readers valued Moore's research into how immigrant Catholics adapted religious practices in America and his analysis of tensions between American and European Catholics. Several noted the book provides context for understanding modern Catholic identity formation. Primary criticisms focused on dense academic prose and overuse of theoretical frameworks. Multiple readers reported difficulty following the arguments through the jargon. One Goodreads reviewer said it "reads more like a dissertation than an accessible historical work." Limited review data exists online: Goodreads: 3.5/5 (4 ratings, 1 review) Amazon: No ratings or reviews found JSTOR: Multiple academic citations but no public reviews Google Books: No public reviews The small number of available reviews suggests this remains primarily an academic text with limited general readership, though it maintains relevance for scholars studying American Catholicism.

Sacred Matters by Robert Orsi This cultural history explores how American Catholics and Protestants practiced everyday religion through material objects and rituals from 1850-1950.

The Churching of America by Roger Finke, Rodney Stark A data-driven examination traces how religious competition and market forces shaped American denominational growth from colonial times through the modern era.

Selling God by David Hall This study analyzes how American religious groups adopted commercial marketing techniques and consumer culture to spread their messages from the 18th century onward.

The Religious History of America by Edwin S. Gaustad, Leigh E. Schmidt This comprehensive overview traces the development of religious movements, institutions and beliefs across American history from pre-colonial times to the present.

Religion in American Life by Jon Butler, Grant Wacker, Randall Balmer This social history examines how religion shaped American culture through the lens of ordinary people's lived experiences across different time periods and regions.

🔍 The book explores how Americans have historically transformed religious figures into commercial and cultural commodities 📚 Author R. Laurence Moore is a professor emeritus at Cornell University who specializes in American religious and intellectual history ⚜️ The book examines how Catholic saints were "Americanized" and adapted into Protestant and secular contexts during the 19th and 20th centuries 🎭 One focus of the book is how religious imagery and saint stories were incorporated into American entertainment, including theater and early films 💫 The work challenges the notion of secularization by showing how religious elements were not eliminated but rather repackaged and commercialized in American culture