Intellectuals

Intellectuals examines the lives and impacts of influential thinkers who shaped modern society through their ideas and writing. Paul Johnson profiles key figures from the 18th through 20th centuries, including Rousseau, Marx, Ibsen, Tolstoy, and Sartre. The book investigates the contrast between these intellectuals' public positions and their private conduct. Johnson presents detailed accounts of their relationships, lifestyles, and personal choices while analyzing how these factors influenced their work and philosophies. Each chapter focuses on a different intellectual, incorporating primary sources and historical documents to construct biographical narratives. The text traces how their ideas spread and evolved into movements that transformed politics, culture, and social structures. This work raises questions about the role of character in shaping ideas and the relationship between personal integrity and public influence. Johnson's analysis challenges readers to consider how theory and practice intersect in the lives of those who seek to remake society.

Readers describe this as a critical examination exposing the personal lives and hypocrisies of influential intellectuals like Rousseau, Marx, and Sartre. Positive reviews highlight: - The detailed research and primary sources - Clear connections between the subjects' behaviors and their ideas - The focus on how intellectuals' private conduct contradicted their public positions - Johnson's direct writing style Common criticisms: - Selection bias in choosing subjects to fit an anti-intellectual narrative - Too much focus on personal flaws rather than ideas - Conservative bias in analysis - Overemphasis on sexual behavior and relationships Ratings: Goodreads: 3.9/5 (2,100+ ratings) Amazon: 4.3/5 (280+ ratings) Sample review: "Johnson methodically destroys the moral authority of those who would remake society according to their theories while failing to live up to basic standards of decency in their own lives." - Amazon reviewer Critical review: "Character assassination masquerading as biography - Johnson seems more interested in gossip than genuine intellectual history." - Goodreads reviewer

The Betrayal of the Intellectuals by Julien Benda The book examines how 20th-century intellectuals abandoned their role as guardians of truth to serve political ideologies.

Explaining Postmodernism by Stephen Hicks This text traces the intellectual history of postmodernism from Rousseau through the modern era, analyzing the philosophers who shaped contemporary thought.

The Opium of the Intellectuals by Raymond Aron A critique of post-war French intellectuals depicts their relationship with Marxist ideology and the consequences of their political commitments.

The Reckless Mind by Mark Lilla The book explores how prominent 20th-century philosophers engaged with and supported totalitarian politics despite their intellectual capabilities.

The Last Intellectuals by Russell Jacoby This work chronicles the decline of public intellectuals in American life and the shift from independent thinkers to specialized academics.

🔖 Paul Johnson wrote "Intellectuals" as a critical examination of influential thinkers who sought to change society but often failed to live up to their own ideals in their personal lives. 📚 The book focuses on figures like Rousseau, Marx, and Sartre, revealing how they frequently abandoned their own children, mistreated women, and lived off the generosity of others while preaching social responsibility. 🎨 Among the subjects profiled is Percy Shelley, who Johnson portrays as running up enormous debts while preaching about the evils of wealth and advocating for free love while treating his wives cruelly. 📖 The work sparked controversy upon its 1988 release for its unflinching look at the private lives of revered intellectual figures, challenging the tendency to separate their ideas from their personal conduct. 🗝️ Johnson's research draws heavily from personal letters, diaries, and contemporary accounts to build detailed portraits that challenge the sanitized public images of these influential thinkers.