📖 Overview
The Danger Tree follows the history of Macfarlane's maternal family, the Goodyears, across multiple generations in Newfoundland. The narrative traces their roots from their arrival on the island through their rise as merchants in Grand Falls and their experiences during both World Wars.
Through personal stories, letters, and memories, Macfarlane reconstructs the lives of his ancestors against the backdrop of Newfoundland's transformation from British colony to Canadian province. Family dynamics, business ventures, and wartime service intersect as the author pieces together his family's past.
The book moves between time periods, connecting events from the early 1900s to the author's own childhood memories of summer visits to his grandmother's house. Macfarlane examines how each generation of his family faced challenges unique to their era while maintaining deep connections to Newfoundland itself.
This memoir-history hybrid explores themes of identity, memory, and the complex relationship between personal stories and broader historical events. The work raises questions about how family legacies persist and transform across generations.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe The Danger Tree as a moving family memoir that weaves together Newfoundland history with personal stories. The book maintains a 4.4/5 rating on Goodreads from 108 ratings.
Readers highlight:
- The lyrical, non-linear writing style
- Detailed portrayal of Newfoundland culture and landscape
- Connection between family history and broader historical events
- Authentic depiction of grief and loss
"The writing is so beautiful it makes you ache," notes one Goodreads reviewer.
Common criticisms:
- Narrative jumps between time periods can be confusing
- Some readers found the pace slow in sections
- A few readers wanted more focus on either the family story or the historical elements rather than both
Amazon reviewers give it 4.5/5 from 21 ratings. The book received the Canadian Authors Association Award for Non-Fiction in 1991.
Several readers mention re-reading the book multiple times, with one noting "I discover something new with each reading."
📚 Similar books
As For Me and My House by Sinclair Ross
A Depression-era Saskatchewan family faces isolation and hardship through journal entries that reveal inner struggles with faith, duty, and personal identity.
The Colony of Unrequited Dreams by Wayne Johnston This work chronicles Newfoundland's path to confederation through the story of Joey Smallwood, weaving personal and political narratives of the maritime province.
The Mountain and the Valley by Ernest Buckler The life story of a Nova Scotia family unfolds through multiple generations, capturing rural Maritime life and the pull between tradition and change.
Fall On Your Knees by Ann-Marie MacDonald A Cape Breton family saga spans four generations, connecting their lives to the coal mines, music, and complex heritage of Nova Scotia.
Random Passage by Bernice Morgan The story follows a young woman's arrival in outport Newfoundland during the 1800s, depicting the harsh realities of coastal settlement life.
The Colony of Unrequited Dreams by Wayne Johnston This work chronicles Newfoundland's path to confederation through the story of Joey Smallwood, weaving personal and political narratives of the maritime province.
The Mountain and the Valley by Ernest Buckler The life story of a Nova Scotia family unfolds through multiple generations, capturing rural Maritime life and the pull between tradition and change.
Fall On Your Knees by Ann-Marie MacDonald A Cape Breton family saga spans four generations, connecting their lives to the coal mines, music, and complex heritage of Nova Scotia.
Random Passage by Bernice Morgan The story follows a young woman's arrival in outport Newfoundland during the 1800s, depicting the harsh realities of coastal settlement life.
🤔 Interesting facts
🌟 Much of the book centers around Macfarlane's mother's family, the Goodyear clan, who were prominent merchants in Grand Falls and Lamaline, Newfoundland
🍁 David Macfarlane wrote the book after discovering a cache of old family letters and documents in his mother's attic following her death
⚔️ The title "The Danger Tree" refers to a tree used as an artillery target marker during WWI at Beaumont-Hamel, where many Newfoundland soldiers lost their lives
🏰 The Goodyear family's original house in Grand Falls was known locally as "The Castle" and was one of the most impressive residences in the town
📜 The book weaves together three generations of family history with Newfoundland's transition from British colony to Canadian province in 1949