A Necessary Evil

In 1921 Calcutta, Captain Sam Wyndham and Sergeant "Surrender-Not" Banerjee investigate the assassination of a prince from one of India's princely states. The case pulls them into the complex political landscape of British India, where maharajahs maintain tenuous alliances with colonial rulers. The investigation takes the duo from the grand palaces of Indian royalty to the gritty underbelly of the city. They must navigate dangerous territory between the British administration, Indian nobility, and rising nationalist movements that threaten the established order. Captain Wyndham confronts his own biases and assumptions as an outsider in India, while Sergeant Banerjee balances his role as a police officer with his identity as an Indian. Through their partnership, the novel examines power dynamics, loyalty, and justice in a society marked by deep divisions and rapid change. The story serves as both a taut detective novel and a window into a pivotal moment in Indian history, exploring themes of colonialism, tradition versus modernity, and the human cost of empire.

Readers note the rich historical details and atmospheric portrayal of 1920s India, particularly appreciating the political intrigue and cultural tensions of the princely states. Many highlight the complex relationship between Captain Wyndham and Sergeant Banerjee as a strength of the series. Readers liked: - Fast-paced investigation with multiple twists - Descriptions of palace life and royal politics - Balance of historical context with mystery elements - Character development from previous books Readers disliked: - Some found the political background sections slowed the pace - A few felt the ending was rushed - Minor historical inaccuracies noted by Indian readers Ratings: Goodreads: 4.17/5 (4,800+ ratings) Amazon: 4.5/5 (1,200+ ratings) "Captures the complexities of colonial India while delivering a solid mystery" - common sentiment in Amazon reviews "More confident and assured than the first book" - frequent Goodreads comment

The Rising Man by Barbara Cleverly This murder mystery set in 1920s Calcutta follows Detective Joe Sandilands through colonial India's political tensions and class divisions.

Death in Bombay by Vikram Chandra A police procedural unfolds in post-independence Mumbai where Inspector Sartaj Singh investigates corruption within the force while navigating the city's criminal underworld.

The Last Kashmiri Rose by Barbara Cleverly Murder investigation in 1920s Bengal reveals secrets of the British Raj and the complex relationships between colonizers and local communities.

The Widows of Malabar Hill by Sujata Massey A female lawyer in 1920s Bombay tackles a murder case that exposes the social and religious tensions of colonial India.

Death of an Englishman by Magdalen Nabb Set in colonial-era Kolkata, this police procedural follows Inspector Das through the investigation of a British officer's murder against the backdrop of India's independence movement.

🔹 The book is set in 1920 India and features a real historical setting: the princely state of Sambalpore, known for its legendary diamond mines and the extravagant lifestyle of its maharajas. 🔹 Author Abir Mukherjee worked as an accountant for twenty years before becoming a full-time writer, drawing inspiration from his Anglo-Indian heritage to create his historical crime series. 🔹 The novel explores the complex political system of British India, where over 500 semi-autonomous princely states existed alongside British-controlled territories, each with their own ruler and customs. 🔹 The protagonist, Sam Wyndham, is partly inspired by real British officers who struggled with opium addiction during their service in India – a significant social issue during the colonial period. 🔹 The book won the 2018 Wilbur Smith Adventure Writing Prize and was selected as one of the Best Crime Books of 2018 by The Times.