College Unranked

College Unranked presents a collection of essays from educators, administrators, and admissions professionals who challenge the current college admissions system. The contributors examine how rankings, standardized testing, and other metrics have transformed higher education into a high-stakes competition. Lloyd Thacker assembles perspectives from across academia to document specific ways that commercialization and marketing have impacted college admissions. The essays explore alternatives to the current system and propose reforms aimed at making the process more equitable and meaningful. The book includes case studies of institutions that have rejected traditional rankings and adopted different approaches to evaluating student potential. Contributors share data, research findings, and firsthand experiences from their work in college admissions and counseling. At its core, College Unranked makes a case for reclaiming the educational mission of college admissions from market forces and commercial interests. The book argues for a return to values-based assessment that prioritizes student development and learning over competitive metrics.

Readers view this book as a critique of college rankings and their influence on higher education. Many found value in the collection of essays from education leaders who challenge the commercialization of college admissions. Readers appreciated: - Clear arguments against rankings-driven admissions - Real examples of how rankings distort education priorities - Practical suggestions for reform - Multiple perspectives from different contributors Common criticisms: - Some essays repeat similar points - Limited coverage of solutions - Academic writing style can be dense - Focus mainly on elite institutions Ratings: Goodreads: 3.4/5 (11 ratings) Amazon: 3.7/5 (4 reviews) One Amazon reviewer noted: "Important message but becomes repetitive." A Goodreads user commented: "Good examination of a broken system, though solutions feel incomplete." Limited reviews exist online, as the book targets education professionals more than general readers.

Where You Go Is Not Who You'll Be by Frank Bruni. This book examines how the college admissions process distorts students' values and explores paths to success beyond elite universities.

The Price of Admission by Daniel Golden. The investigation reveals how wealth, power, and influence affect college admissions at America's top universities.

Who Gets In and Why by Jeffrey Selingo. The book provides an inside look at the college admissions process through the lens of three different institutions over the course of one year.

The Years That Matter Most by Paul Tough. Through research and individual stories, this work examines how the college admissions system impacts social mobility and inequality in America.

Excellent Sheep by William Deresiewicz. The book critiques the pressure-cooker culture of elite education and its effects on students' development and learning.

🎓 Lloyd Thacker left his 23-year career as a college admission counselor to establish the Education Conservancy, a non-profit organization dedicated to reforming the college admissions process. 📚 The book features essays from 15 different college presidents and education leaders, making it a collaborative critique of college rankings systems. 🏫 Released in 2005, the book helped spark a movement among colleges to boycott the U.S. News & World Report rankings, with several institutions refusing to participate in the rankings process. 📊 Thacker argues that college rankings have turned education into a commodity, leading institutions to focus more on improving their ranking metrics than on actual educational quality. 🎯 The project that led to this book received support from the American Association of Collegiate Registrars and Admissions Officers (AACRAO), highlighting its significance within the education community.