The New Case Against Immigration

The New Case Against Immigration examines modern immigration to the United States and its effects on American society. Executive Director of the Center for Immigration Studies Mark Krikorian argues that while immigration worked well in America's past, current conditions make it incompatible with modern society. Krikorian presents research and data on immigration's impact across multiple sectors including the economy, national security, assimilation, and social services. The book analyzes both legal and illegal immigration, making distinctions between different types of immigration policies and their outcomes. Through historical comparisons and policy analysis, Krikorian develops his central thesis that the modern welfare state and technological society create fundamentally different circumstances for immigration than existed in previous eras. His argument focuses on systemic and structural factors rather than critiquing immigrants themselves. The book contributes to immigration policy debates by examining how societal changes affect the role and impact of immigration, raising questions about compatibility between mass immigration and advanced industrial democracy. These themes resonate with ongoing national discussions about immigration reform and American identity.

Readers describe this book as a data-driven argument against current U.S. immigration policies. Many note it presents statistics and research rather than emotional appeals. Readers appreciated: - Clear organization and readability - Focus on economic and social data - Discussion of both legal and illegal immigration - Historical context and policy analysis - Distinction from anti-immigrant rhetoric Common criticisms: - Data interpretation seen as selective by some readers - Limited discussion of counter-arguments - Conclusions viewed as predetermined - Policy recommendations deemed impractical One reader noted: "Makes valid points about integration challenges but oversimplifies complex demographic shifts." Ratings: Amazon: 4.1/5 (83 reviews) Goodreads: 3.7/5 (126 ratings) Most critical reviews focused on methodology rather than conclusions. Several academic readers questioned statistical analysis methods but praised the comprehensive research. Conservative readers endorsed the policy recommendations while liberal readers disputed the interpretations.

Who Are We?: The Challenges to America's National Identity by Samuel P. Huntington Examines immigration's effects on American culture, institutions, and national identity through historical and demographic analysis.

Alien Nation: Common Sense About America's Immigration Disaster by Peter Brimelow Presents data-driven arguments about immigration's impact on American society, economics, and population patterns.

The Death of the West by Patrick J. Buchanan Documents demographic changes in Western nations and their relationship to immigration policies and birth rates.

We Wanted Workers: Unraveling the Immigration Narrative by George J. Borjas Analyzes immigration's economic effects through labor market statistics and policy outcomes.

Exodus: How Migration is Changing Our World by Paul Collier Examines migration's effects on both sending and receiving countries through economic and social science research.

📚 Mark Krikorian serves as Executive Director of the Center for Immigration Studies, a think tank that advocates for lower immigration levels to the United States. 🗓️ Published in 2008, the book argues not against immigration itself, but rather that modern conditions make mass immigration incompatible with contemporary American society. 🔍 The book challenges both liberal and conservative conventional wisdom about immigration, addressing economic, cultural, and security concerns rather than focusing solely on illegal immigration. 🌍 Krikorian, himself the son of Armenian immigrants, makes a distinction between historical immigration patterns and modern immigration, citing technological advances in transportation and communication as game-changers. 📊 The book includes analysis of how the American welfare state, which didn't exist during previous waves of immigration, fundamentally changes the economic impact of immigration compared to earlier eras.