The Shock of the Old

The Shock of the Old challenges conventional narratives about technological progress and innovation. Rather than focusing on breakthrough inventions, this historical analysis examines how established technologies continue to shape the modern world. Author David Edgerton traces the ongoing impact of technologies like corrugated iron, bicycles, and horses through the twentieth century. His research spans multiple continents and cultures, demonstrating how older innovations remain vital even as newer ones emerge. The book reframes technology's role in war, agriculture, and daily life by examining actual usage patterns rather than invention dates. Through detailed examples and statistics, Edgerton documents the persistence and adaptation of what many consider obsolete technologies. This work questions standard accounts of technological determinism and presents an alternative view of how societies interact with tools and machines. The central argument proposes that understanding technology requires studying what people actually use rather than what they invent.

Readers value the book's challenge to standard technological narratives and its focus on maintenance and continued use of "old" technologies rather than just invention dates. Many appreciate Edgerton's examples of how older technologies like horses and sewing machines remained relevant long after their supposed obsolescence. Common praise focuses on the alternative perspective of looking at technology "in use" rather than just at innovation moments. Readers highlight the book's examination of technologies in developing nations and its challenge to Western-centric tech histories. Main criticisms cite repetitive writing and academic tone. Some readers found the arguments belabored and wanted more detail on specific technologies. A few note that the contrarian stance sometimes feels forced. Ratings: Goodreads: 3.9/5 (876 ratings) Amazon: 4.2/5 (89 ratings) Representative review: "Makes you question everything you thought you knew about the history of technology. Sometimes dry but worth pushing through." - Goodreads reviewer

Energy and Civilization by Vaclav Smil This history traces how energy technologies and usage patterns shaped human societies from pre-agricultural times through the modern era.

How We Got to Now by Steven Berlin Johnson The book examines six fundamental technologies that enable modern life by following their development through centuries of use and adaptation.

The Nature of Technology by W. Brian Arthur This analysis presents technology as an evolving system that combines existing components rather than a series of individual breakthrough inventions.

Stuff Matters by Mark Miodownik The text explores the history and development of ten materials that surround us in daily life, from concrete to chocolate.

The Cigarette Century by Allan M. Brandt This history uses cigarette manufacturing and marketing to demonstrate how technologies spread through society and become embedded in culture.

🔹 Despite widespread beliefs about technology always moving "forward," Edgerton shows how many old technologies like the Singer sewing machine and the bicycle have remained vital and relevant throughout the modern era. 🔹 The book challenges the common "innovation-centric" view of history by focusing on what technologies people actually used rather than what was newly invented, introducing the concept of "use-centered" history. 🔹 Author David Edgerton is a professor at King's College London and coined the term "techno-nationalism" to describe how nations often claim technological achievements as uniquely their own. 🔹 The book reveals that corrugated iron, a seemingly mundane material, was one of the most important building materials of the 20th century, used extensively in colonial territories and still vital in developing nations today. 🔹 During World War II, horses were actually more numerous and often more reliable than motorized vehicles in the German army, contradicting popular assumptions about twentieth-century warfare being fully mechanized.