📖 Overview
Charlotte Holmes investigates cases under the pseudonym "Sherlock" in Victorian London, hiding her true identity due to the era's restrictions on women. When Lady Ingram seeks help locating a missing former love, Charlotte must take the case despite Lady Ingram being married to Charlotte's own close friend Lord Ingram.
The investigation leads Charlotte through London's high society drawing rooms and its dangerous back alleys as she pursues multiple interconnected mysteries. Her work is complicated by family obligations, romantic entanglements, and the machinations of her nemesis Moriarty.
This second installment in the Lady Sherlock series builds on the world established in A Study in Scarlet Women while expanding the scope of both the mysteries and character relationships. Charlotte continues to challenge Victorian gender roles through her detective work while navigating complex personal and professional relationships.
The novel explores themes of identity, social constraints, and the tension between duty and desire in Victorian society. Through its gender-swapped Holmes premise, it raises questions about power, perception, and the ways people must sometimes work within or around societal limitations to achieve their goals.
👀 Reviews
Readers praise the complex mystery plot and the chemistry between Charlotte Holmes and Lord Ingram. Many note Thomas's attention to period details and social commentary on women's roles in Victorian society. The book maintains high ratings: 4.15/5 on Goodreads (17,000+ ratings) and 4.4/5 on Amazon (900+ ratings).
Common praise points:
- Charlotte's sharp deductions and analytical mind
- The slow-burn romance elements
- Growth of secondary characters
- Writing quality and dialogue
Main criticisms:
- Plot pacing slows in middle sections
- Some find Charlotte too cold or detached
- Mystery resolution feels rushed to some readers
- A few note the romance overshadows the mystery
Several reviewers mention the book improves upon the first in the series. Reader Emma K on Goodreads writes: "The cases interweave brilliantly and the emotional stakes feel higher." Amazon reviewer Mark T notes: "The Victorian setting feels lived-in rather than just window dressing."
📚 Similar books
A Study in Scarlet Women by Sherry Thomas
A female Sherlock Holmes investigates murders in Victorian London while navigating society's restrictions on women.
The Agency: A Spy in the House by Y.S. Lee A reformed thief joins a women's detective agency in Victorian England to solve cases through infiltration and deception.
The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie by Alan Bradley An eleven-year-old chemistry prodigy in 1950s England uses her knowledge to solve murder mysteries at her family estate.
Murder on Black Swan Lane by Andrea Penrose A noblewoman teams with a chemist to investigate deaths in Regency London's scientific circles.
A Curious Beginning by Deanna Raybourn A Victorian butterfly hunter becomes embroiled in murder investigations after partnering with a mysterious private inquiry agent.
The Agency: A Spy in the House by Y.S. Lee A reformed thief joins a women's detective agency in Victorian England to solve cases through infiltration and deception.
The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie by Alan Bradley An eleven-year-old chemistry prodigy in 1950s England uses her knowledge to solve murder mysteries at her family estate.
Murder on Black Swan Lane by Andrea Penrose A noblewoman teams with a chemist to investigate deaths in Regency London's scientific circles.
A Curious Beginning by Deanna Raybourn A Victorian butterfly hunter becomes embroiled in murder investigations after partnering with a mysterious private inquiry agent.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔍 This book reimagines the Sherlock Holmes character as Charlotte Holmes, a Victorian woman who must solve cases under the guise of being the fictitious brother of her friend Lord Ingram.
🎭 Charlotte Holmes possesses synesthesia, experiencing tastes as colors, which adds a unique dimension to her deductive abilities and character development.
📚 Author Sherry Thomas learned English as a second language at age 13, and didn't begin writing novels in English until her late twenties.
🗝️ The title references Belgravia, an affluent London district that became prominent in the Victorian era and was home to many aristocratic families.
🎬 The "Lady Sherlock" series, of which this book is the second installment, was optioned for television development by Playground Entertainment, the company behind "Downton Abbey."