📖 Overview
Italian police detective Aurelio Zen arrives in Naples seeking a quiet post, but finds himself managing a harbor police station where corruption operates openly. The story parallels Mozart's opera Così fan tutte, with chapter titles drawn directly from Da Ponte's libretto.
While Naples appears immune to Italy's anti-corruption "Clean Hands" movement, a mysterious group begins removing corrupt officials and mafia figures under the banner of "Clean Streets." Zen occupies himself with an elaborate scheme involving his landlady's two daughters and their relationships with local criminals.
This fifth installment in the Aurelio Zen series combines elements of police procedural with comic opera, exploring themes of deception, loyalty, and the complex social structures of modern Naples. The novel builds on the tension between surface appearances and underlying truth, both in matters of love and law enforcement.
👀 Reviews
Readers call this one of the funnier entries in the Aurelio Zen series, with many appreciating Dibdin's parody of the Mozart opera and its themes of mistaken identities and romantic deceptions. The Naples setting receives praise for its vivid descriptions and local color.
Readers liked:
- The comic timing and farcical elements
- Complex plot twists that come together in the end
- Rich portrayal of Neapolitan culture and corruption
Readers disliked:
- Too many characters to keep track of
- Plot can become convoluted
- Some found the opera references pretentious
- Less mystery/crime focus than other Zen books
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.8/5 (766 ratings)
Amazon: 4.1/5 (58 ratings)
"A delightful romp through Naples" - Goodreads reviewer
"Gets too caught up in being clever" - Amazon reviewer
"The most entertaining Zen novel" - LibraryThing user
📚 Similar books
Death at La Fenice by Donna Leon
A Venice police commissioner investigates murder in the opera world, blending musical culture with Italian criminal investigation in ways that mirror Dibdin's operatic structure.
The Day of the Owl by Leonardo Sciascia Set in Sicily, this investigation into a mafia killing captures the same sense of institutional corruption and regional Italian politics found in Cosi Fan Tutti.
The Shape of Water by Andrea Camilleri Inspector Montalbano navigates Sicilian society and politics while solving crimes, presenting the same mix of Mediterranean culture and police work as Zen's adventures.
The Name of the Father by Carlo Lucarelli An investigation in Bologna during the Years of Lead presents Italian police work against a backdrop of social upheaval, matching Dibdin's exploration of systemic corruption.
Total Chaos by Jean-Claude Izzo Set in Marseilles, this Mediterranean noir follows a detective through port city corruption and criminal networks that parallel Zen's Naples experience.
The Day of the Owl by Leonardo Sciascia Set in Sicily, this investigation into a mafia killing captures the same sense of institutional corruption and regional Italian politics found in Cosi Fan Tutti.
The Shape of Water by Andrea Camilleri Inspector Montalbano navigates Sicilian society and politics while solving crimes, presenting the same mix of Mediterranean culture and police work as Zen's adventures.
The Name of the Father by Carlo Lucarelli An investigation in Bologna during the Years of Lead presents Italian police work against a backdrop of social upheaval, matching Dibdin's exploration of systemic corruption.
Total Chaos by Jean-Claude Izzo Set in Marseilles, this Mediterranean noir follows a detective through port city corruption and criminal networks that parallel Zen's Naples experience.
🤔 Interesting facts
🎭 The book's title and plot directly mirror Mozart's 1790 opera "Così fan tutte," which similarly features romantic deceptions and partner-swapping schemes.
🇮🇹 Naples, where the novel is set, has historically been one of Italy's most crime-ridden cities, with the Camorra crime syndicate maintaining significant influence since the 19th century.
📚 Aurelio Zen, the protagonist, appears in 11 novels by Michael Dibdin, published between 1988 and 2007, making it one of the most successful Italian-set crime series in English literature.
🎬 The Zen series was adapted for television by the BBC in 2011, starring Rufus Sewell as the titular detective, though "Cosi Fan Tutti" was not among the episodes produced.
✍️ Author Michael Dibdin lived in Italy for four years as an English teacher, giving him intimate knowledge of Italian culture and society that he wove into his works with notable authenticity.