Where There's a Will

Where There's a Will is a Nero Wolfe mystery novel from 1940 featuring the eccentric detective and his assistant Archie Goodwin. The story centers on the Hawthorne family's inheritance dispute after wealthy Noel Hawthorne leaves his fortune to a young woman outside the family, while his three sisters and widow receive only token bequests. Private detective Nero Wolfe must navigate the tensions between Noel's sisters (named April, May, and June), his scarred and bitter widow Daisy, and the mysterious beneficiary Naomi Karn. The investigation takes an unexpected turn when evidence emerges that Noel's death was not from natural causes but murder. The case requires Wolfe to untangle complex family dynamics, hidden motives, and the true circumstances of Noel's death from his Manhattan brownstone headquarters. The investigation unfolds against the backdrop of pre-World War II New York City, with Wolfe's methods contrasting with those of the official police investigation. Beyond its function as a mystery, the novel examines themes of family loyalty, revenge, and the power of wealth to both unite and divide. The peculiar will at the center of the story serves as a lens through which to view the characters' true natures and relationships.

Readers rank this as a mid-tier Nero Wolfe mystery. Many note it delivers the expected Wolfe/Archie dynamic and interactions at the brownstone, but with less investigation scenes than usual. Liked: - Multiple inheritance plot twists - Rich character details about Wolfe's daily routines - Strong dialogue between Wolfe and Archie - The unique will reading scene Disliked: - Too much time spent at the brownstone vs. field investigation - Several reviewers found the ending rushed - Some felt the suspects weren't developed enough - A few noted the mystery was too easy to solve Ratings: Goodreads: 4.13/5 (1,834 ratings) Amazon: 4.5/5 (156 ratings) "The plotting is solid but the real joy is watching Wolfe and Archie's verbal sparring" - Goodreads reviewer "Less dynamic than other Wolfe stories, but the brownstone scenes make up for it" - Amazon reviewer

The Big Sleep by Raymond Chandler A private detective navigates deception and family secrets while investigating the blackmail of a wealthy client's daughter.

The Moving Target by Ross Macdonald Detective Lew Archer pursues leads through California's elite social circles after a millionaire vanishes without explanation.

The Roman Hat Mystery by Ellery Queen A murdered man in a theater leads to an investigation filled with methodical deduction and hidden clues.

Too Many Cooks by Rex Stout Nero Wolfe leaves his comfort zone to solve a murder at a gathering of master chefs.

The Daughter of Time by Josephine Tey A bedridden detective applies logical deduction to solve a centuries-old historical mystery about Richard III.

🔍 Nero Wolfe's brownstone on West 35th Street became so iconic that fans still visit the fictional address today, treating it as a real New York City landmark. 🌺 Rex Stout gave Nero Wolfe a passion for orchids as a character trait after extensively researching orchid cultivation himself, and he later became president of the New York Orchid Society. 📚 Where There's a Will was published in 1940, during a period when inheritance disputes were particularly common due to the economic aftermath of the Great Depression. 🎭 The character of Archie Goodwin was revolutionary for detective fiction, as he served not just as a narrator but as a dynamic counterpoint to Wolfe's sedentary lifestyle. ✍️ Rex Stout wrote 33 Nero Wolfe novels and 39 novellas over four decades, making it one of the longest-running detective series in American literature.