To Believe in Women

To Believe in Women examines the contributions of lesbian women to the American women's rights movement of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Historian Lillian Faderman researches and documents the lives of prominent suffragists and education reformers whose same-sex relationships influenced their activism. Through extensive archival materials including letters, diaries, and contemporary accounts, Faderman reconstructs the personal and professional lives of figures like Susan B. Anthony, Jane Addams, M. Carey Thomas and others. The text explores how these women's freedom from traditional marriage allowed them to dedicate themselves to social causes and form supportive networks with other female reformers. This historical analysis challenges conventional narratives about early feminism by highlighting the role of same-sex relationships and questioning assumptions about the private lives of key movement leaders. Faderman demonstrates how same-sex partnerships provided both emotional sustenance and practical support that enabled women to pursue radical social change. The work raises broader questions about the connections between personal identity, intimate relationships, and political activism in movements for social justice. By recovering these hidden histories, the book expands understanding of how marginalized identities have shaped American reform movements.

Readers appreciate Faderman's thorough research and documentation of lesbian relationships among early American suffragists and feminist leaders. Many note how the book reveals historical examples of same-sex partnerships while maintaining academic rigor. Readers highlight the accessibility of Faderman's writing style and her ability to connect historical figures' personal lives to their public accomplishments. Multiple reviewers mention learning new information about well-known historical figures like Jane Addams and Susan B. Anthony. Some readers find the writing dry in sections and note that certain chapters feel repetitive. A few reviewers wanted more analysis of class and racial dynamics among the women discussed. Ratings: Goodreads: 4.0/5 (276 ratings) Amazon: 4.4/5 (28 ratings) Sample review: "Faderman makes a compelling case for how same-sex relationships enabled women's achievements in reform movements, but at times the connections feel stretched." - Goodreads reviewer

Hidden from History by Barbara Smith This historical examination reveals the untold stories of lesbian and bisexual women who shaped American social movements from 1900-1960.

The Female World of Love and Ritual by Carroll Smith-Rosenberg The book explores intimate relationships between nineteenth-century American women through their letters, diaries, and social customs.

Odd Girls and Twilight Lovers by Lillian Faderman This history traces lesbian life and culture in twentieth-century America through personal accounts and social documentation.

Surpassing the Love of Men by Lillian Faderman The text examines romantic friendships and love between women from the Renaissance to the present through literature and historical records.

Boston Marriages by Esther D. Rothblum and Kathleen A. Bergen The book documents the lives of nineteenth-century women who formed committed domestic partnerships outside traditional marriage structures.

🔷 Author Lillian Faderman is often called the "mother of lesbian history" and has won multiple Lambda Literary Awards for her groundbreaking work in LGBTQ+ studies 🔷 The book reveals how many influential 19th-century women's rights activists, including Susan B. Anthony and Jane Addams, formed romantic relationships with other women that fueled their dedication to feminist causes 🔷 Before writing this book, Faderman spent over two decades researching letters, diaries, and other primary sources to uncover the hidden relationships between women reformers 🔷 The book challenges the traditional notion that spinsterhood was a barrier to women's achievements, showing instead how freedom from traditional marriage often allowed women to pursue education, careers, and social reform 🔷 Many of the women featured in the book lived in "Boston marriages" - long-term, committed relationships between two women that were socially acceptable in the 19th century, though their romantic nature was often downplayed or ignored by historians