The Mostly True Story of Jack

Jack arrives in the small Iowa town of Hazelwood to stay with his aunt and uncle while his parents go through a divorce. Upon arrival, he discovers that people notice him for the first time in his life - a stark contrast to his previous existence in San Francisco where he seemed to fade into invisibility. The town of Hazelwood holds secrets beneath its quiet exterior, with mysterious disappearances of children in its past and strange events tied to an old house. As Jack makes friends and explores his new surroundings, he becomes entangled in the town's hidden magical elements and its connection to an ancient power in the earth. Through Jack's journey to understand his place in Hazelwood and his own identity, the story explores themes of belonging, sacrifice, and the complex relationship between memory and truth. The book blends elements of fantasy with the everyday challenges of finding one's place in the world.

Readers describe this middle-grade novel as mysterious and dark, with many noting it defies typical genre categorization. The book holds a 3.7/5 rating on Goodreads from 2,300+ ratings. Readers praised: - The unique blend of fantasy and reality - Complex themes about belonging and identity - Strong world-building - Unpredictable plot twists Common criticisms: - Slow pacing in the first third - Confusing narrative structure - Too dark/intense for younger readers - Some plot threads left unresolved Multiple reviews mention the book requires patience, with one Goodreads reviewer noting "it takes time for the pieces to come together." Amazon reviewers (3.9/5 from 89 ratings) frequently mentioned the book's originality but cautioned it may not suit readers seeking straightforward fantasy. A recurring theme in reviews is that the book appeals more to adults than its intended middle-grade audience, with School Library Journal readers suggesting it works best for ages 12 and up.

Savvy by Ingrid Law A young girl with a supernatural power she doesn't want travels to meet family members who share her secret abilities.

The Real Boy by Anne Ursu An orphan who works in a magic shop discovers truths about his identity while trying to save his town from a mysterious illness.

The House of Hidden Wonders by Sharon Cameron A girl living in underground tunnels beneath Edinburgh becomes entangled in magic and mysteries that connect to her past.

Tuesdays at the Castle by Jessica Day George Three siblings protect their magical castle home from invaders who seek to steal its power and their birthright.

The Night Garden by Polly Horvath A girl who lives on a remote farm discovers her home contains enchanted gardens with the power to grant wishes.

🌟 Kelly Barnhill won the prestigious Newbery Medal in 2017 for her later novel "The Girl Who Drank the Moon" 🌿 The book explores Celtic mythology and magical realism while being set in modern-day Iowa 📚 This was Kelly Barnhill's debut novel, published in 2011 after she spent years working as a teacher and bartender 🏠 The town of Hazelwood, Iowa, where the story takes place, is described as having magical properties that make people either invisible or unforgettable 🎭 The character of Jack is based on Barnhill's own son, who struggled with feeling invisible and out of place during his childhood