The Falls

Detective Inspector John Rebus investigates the disappearance of a young female student in Edinburgh, while facing pressure from a powerful banking family and police leadership. The case connects to other Edinburgh mysteries, including historical coffin dolls found on Arthur's Seat and the infamous Burke and Hare murders. The investigation spans both modern and historical Edinburgh, with Rebus and his colleague DC Siobhan Clarke pursuing parallel tracks through the city's present-day streets and centuries-old secrets. The police team must navigate departmental politics and personal loyalties while racing to locate the missing student. DC Clarke faces a pivotal career decision as she works the case, while Rebus confronts institutional changes brought by the new female Chief Superintendent Gill Templer. The investigation draws them into Edinburgh's banking world and its connections to the city's darker history. The Falls examines themes of power, institutional loyalty, and how the past continues to influence the present in Scottish society. The novel explores the evolution of policing and the tension between traditional methods and modern reforms.

Readers found The Falls to be a solid Inspector Rebus mystery but not among Rankin's strongest works. The dual investigations - a missing student and a historical case involving miniature coffins - created an engaging puzzle. Readers liked: - The Edinburgh setting details - The complex layering of past and present cases - Character development of Siobhan Clarke - The incorporation of real historical miniature coffins from Arthur's Seat Readers disliked: - Slower pacing in the middle sections - Less gritty atmosphere compared to other Rebus books - Some found the resolution unsatisfying - Internet/technology aspects felt dated Ratings: Goodreads: 4.0/5 (18,000+ ratings) Amazon: 4.3/5 (450+ reviews) Common reader comments: "Great Edinburgh atmosphere but drags in places" "Interesting historical elements but lacks the usual Rebus edge" "The internet chat room sections haven't aged well" "Good mystery but takes too long to get going"

The Lewis Man by Peter May In this Isle of Lewis mystery, a detective investigates a preserved bog body while uncovering dark secrets from Scotland's past and navigating complex police politics.

Broken Ground by Val McDermid Detective Chief Inspector Karen Pirie investigates a body found in the Scottish Highlands while dealing with departmental tensions and historical connections to WWII.

A Small Death in the Great Glen by A.D. Scott A newspaper reporter in 1950s Highland Scotland pursues a murder case that connects to both local power structures and long-buried community secrets.

The Blackhouse by Peter May A Edinburgh detective returns to his Isle of Lewis roots to solve a murder that links to his own past and ancient island traditions.

Now We Are Dead by Stuart MacBride Detective Chief Inspector Roberta Steel pursues a case through Aberdeen's criminal underworld while fighting against police department politics and her own career challenges.

🔍 The wooden dolls in tiny coffins mentioned in the book are based on real artifacts discovered in 1836 on Edinburgh's Arthur's Seat - 17 miniature coffins containing dressed wooden figures that remain unexplained to this day. 🏰 Edinburgh's underground vaults, which feature in the story's historical elements, were once home to thousands of people living in extreme poverty during the Industrial Revolution, and are now considered one of Scotland's most haunted locations. ✍️ Ian Rankin wrote his first Inspector Rebus novel, "Knots & Crosses," while a graduate student at Edinburgh University, initially intending it to be a modern retelling of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. 🎯 Burke and Hare, referenced in the novel, were real-life serial killers who murdered 16 people in Edinburgh (1827-1828) to sell their bodies to medical schools, leading to major reforms in anatomical research laws. 👮 The character of DC Siobhan Clarke was originally intended to appear in just one book but became so popular with readers that Rankin made her a permanent fixture in the series.