Paper Valentine

Hannah Wagnor's town faces a series of murders during a brutal summer heatwave. The victims are young girls whose bodies are staged with paper valentines and paper decorations. Hannah is visited by the ghost of her recently deceased best friend Lillian, who won't leave her side. As more victims appear, Hannah finds herself drawn into investigating the murders while navigating her complex relationship with Lillian's lingering spirit. The story combines elements of supernatural horror, murder mystery, and coming-of-age drama. Hannah must confront both human and ghostly presences as she searches for answers about the killer stalking her community. Through themes of friendship, grief, and identity, Paper Valentine explores how past relationships continue to shape us even after they end. The novel examines the ways young people cope with loss and find their own strength in the face of darkness.

Readers describe Paper Valentine as a unique blend of ghost story and murder mystery, though many found the pacing slow in the first half. The paranormal elements and murder investigation take a backseat to character development and relationship dynamics. Readers praised: - Complex portrayal of grief and eating disorders - Authentic teenage friendships and romance - Atmospheric writing style - Blend of creepy and sweet moments Common criticisms: - Plot moves too slowly - Mystery element feels underdeveloped - Some found the ghost storyline distracting from the main plot - Romance appears abruptly Ratings: Goodreads: 3.7/5 (11,000+ ratings) Amazon: 4/5 (80+ ratings) One reader noted: "The murder mystery takes longer to unfold than expected, but the character relationships make it worth the wait." Another commented: "More contemporary fiction with ghost elements than true paranormal thriller - adjust expectations accordingly."

The Replacement by Brenna Yovanoff This supernatural mystery follows a teen who investigates changeling folklore in his town while dark forces threaten the children of the community.

Imaginary Girls by Nova Ren Suma The story centers on two sisters caught in a web of death, secrets, and unexplained phenomena at a reservoir where a body surfaces.

The Name of the Star by Maureen Johnson A boarding school student becomes involved in a murder investigation when a Jack the Ripper copycat killer terrorizes London with crimes only she can see.

Anna Dressed in Blood by Kendare Blake A ghost hunter falls for a deadly spirit while investigating a series of supernatural murders in a small town.

The Diviners by Libba Bray In 1920s New York, a girl with supernatural abilities must stop a serial killer who uses occult rituals to murder victims.

🦋 While writing Paper Valentine, author Brenna Yovanoff drew inspiration from her childhood fascination with ghost stories and urban legends in her hometown of Denver, Colorado. 📚 The book's portrayal of anorexia and its impact was influenced by the author's personal experiences with eating disorders during her teenage years. 🌙 The murders in the novel were loosely inspired by real-life serial killings that occurred in Kansas during the 1980s. 💀 The protagonist Hannah's ability to see ghosts reflects traditional folklore about the "thin places" between life and death that occur during the hottest days of summer. 🎨 The paper valentine motif throughout the book is based on Victorian-era courtship customs, where intricate paper valentines were often kept as treasured keepsakes and family heirlooms.