Dereliction of Duty

Dereliction of Duty examines the pivotal decisions and leadership failures that led to America's involvement in the Vietnam War. The book focuses on President Lyndon B. Johnson's administration and the complex relationships between civilian leadership and military commanders during the critical period of 1963-1965. Based on extensive research and declassified documents, H.R. McMaster analyzes the roles of key figures including Defense Secretary Robert McNamara, the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and President Johnson himself. The narrative traces how miscommunication, political maneuvering, and institutional dysfunction shaped the escalation of U.S. military involvement in Southeast Asia. Written by McMaster while he was a major in the U.S. Army, the book draws from his military background and doctoral research at the University of North Carolina. The work emerged from his experiences studying Vietnam War accounts as a West Point cadet and his subsequent service as a combat commander. The book stands as a critical examination of civil-military relations and the consequences of leadership decisions during times of war. It raises fundamental questions about accountability, strategic planning, and the relationship between military advice and political objectives.

Readers emphasize the book's detailed research into decision-making failures during Vietnam War escalation, particularly focusing on conflicts between military leaders and politicians. Many note it provides clear documentation of how military advice was ignored or manipulated. Readers appreciate: - Thorough use of declassified documents and meeting notes - Clear explanation of military-civilian relationship breakdown - Specific examples of communication failures between Joint Chiefs and McNamara Common criticisms: - Dense writing style with heavy military jargon - Too focused on meetings/bureaucracy vs. battlefield outcomes - Ends in 1965, leaving later war years uncovered Ratings: Goodreads: 4.3/5 (2,900+ ratings) Amazon: 4.6/5 (750+ ratings) Reader quote: "McMaster methodically builds his case like a prosecutor, showing exactly how each misstep led to deeper involvement." - Amazon reviewer Multiple readers note the book feels academic rather than narrative-driven, but value its contributions to understanding strategic failures.

The Best and the Brightest by David Halberstam Chronicles how Kennedy and Johnson's intellectual advisers led America into the Vietnam War through a series of misguided policies and decisions.

Lessons in Disaster: McGeorge Bundy and the Path to War in Vietnam by Gordon M. Goldstein Examines National Security Adviser McGeorge Bundy's role in Vietnam policy-making and the failures of strategic decision-making during the escalation period.

Supreme Command: Soldiers, Statesmen, and Leadership in Wartime by Eliot A. Cohen Analyzes the relationship between civilian leaders and military commanders through historical case studies of wartime decision-making.

Presidents of War by Michael Beschloss Explores how U.S. presidents from Madison to Johnson managed military conflicts and navigated relationships with military leadership.

The War Within: A Secret White House History 2006-2008 by Bob Woodward Details the internal decision-making processes and civil-military tensions during the Iraq War's critical period.

✯ H. R. McMaster later served as National Security Advisor to President Trump (2017-2018), bringing unique practical experience to his academic analysis. ✯ The book's title comes from the author's belief that military leaders failed in their duty to provide frank and fearless advice to civilian leadership during the Vietnam War. ✯ The research included access to over 4,000 pages of previously classified documents and materials from the Johnson Presidential Library. ✯ Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara admitted in later years that many of McMaster's criticisms about the administration's handling of the war were accurate. ✯ The book began as McMaster's Ph.D. dissertation at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and took five years to complete while he was simultaneously serving as an active-duty Army officer.